All-time Sheffield United tier list
181 players who played for the Sheffield Utd, greatest for the team first; search for anyone else. Rank all-time Sheffield United from S to F.
Place at least 10 to submit your ranking (0 so far).
Save to my profile keeps it to come back to and keep ranking. Submit your ranking adds it to this month's top list.
S
A
B
C
D
E
F
Drag a tile into a tier, or tap it then tap a tier
Phil JagielkaSHU
.png/330px-Aaron_Ramsdale_2019_(cropped).png)
Aaron RamsdaleGK · SHU
Stephen QuinnMF · SHU
_(cropped).jpg/330px-Chelsea_2_Sheffield_Utd_2_(48655606657)_(cropped).jpg)
George BaldockSHU
Alan Kelly Jr.GK · SHU
Iliman NdiayeSHU
Roger NilsenDF · SHU
.jpg/330px-Maguire_Man_Utd_vs_Chelsea_(cropped).jpg)
Harry MaguireSHU
James BeattieFW · SHU
Paddy KennyGK · SHU
Alan HodgkinsonGK · SHU
Keith GillespieSHU
.jpg/330px-Peter_Withe_(1982).jpg)
Peter WitheFW · SHU
Sander BergeMF · SHU
.jpg/330px-John_Brayford_1412024_(2).jpg)
John BrayfordDF · SHU
BDBrian Deane
FW · SHU
William FoulkeGK · SHU
HHHao Haidong
FW · SHU
_in_the_1994_World_Cup_(cropped).jpg/330px-Luca_Marchegiani_makes_the_save_against_Norway_(Jostein_Flo)_in_the_1994_World_Cup_(cropped).jpg)
Jostein FloFW · SHU
Kyle WalkerSHU
Rob PageDF · SHU
Stuart McCallMF · SHU
SMShaun Murphy
DF · SHU
PNPeter Ndlovu
FW · SHU
LALen Allchurch
SHU
Gary SpeedSHU
Arthur BrownFW · SHU
Paul PeschisolidoFW · SHU
GNGary Naysmith
SHU
Traianos DellasDF · SHU
Ched EvansFW · SHU
Mick JonesFW · SHU
LTLi Tie
MF/FW · SHU
David CarneyMF · SHU
.jpg/330px-Jimmy_Johnstone_(cropped).jpg)
Jimmy JohnstoneSHU
Phil ThompsonDF · SHU
Alejandro SabellaMF · SHU
Martin PetersMF · SHU
Michael DoyleMF · SHU
PSPatrick Suffo
FW · SHU
JAJack Alderson
GK · SHU
Alf CommonFW · SHU
Paul McGrathSHU
Sun JihaiSHU
.jpg/330px-Ethan_Ampadu_With_Wales_2020_(cropped).jpg)
Ethan AmpaduMF/DF · SHU
Ciaran ClarkSHU
Don HutchisonMF · SHU
Stewart HoustonSHU
Dean SaundersFW · SHU
.jpg/330px-Vinnie_Jones_ComicCon_(cropped2).jpg)
Vinnie JonesMF · SHU
.JPG/330px-LutonShelton_(cropped).JPG)
Luton SheltonFW · SHU
Jan Åge FjørtoftFW · SHU
Keith CurleDF · SHU
Morgan Gibbs-WhiteSHU
Toni KallioDF · SHU
.jpg/330px-Lee_Hendrie_(2000).jpg)
Lee HendrieMF · SHU
Jordan AyewFW · SHU
.jpg/330px-Tyler_Bindon_(2026).jpg)
Tyler BindonSHU
ZMZé Maria
DF · SHU
.jpg/330px-Jack_Rodwell_2013_(cropped).jpg)
Jack RodwellMF · SHU
Claude DavisDF · SHU
DGDon Givens
FW · SHU
Paul HallFW · SHU
Anthony StokesFW · SHU
David UnsworthSHU
DKDavid Kelly
FW · SHU
Ahmed FathyMF · SHU
Chris WilderDF · SHU
Rhian BrewsterFW · SHU
.jpg/330px-Richard_Wright_(Ipswich_goalkeeper).jpg)
Richard WrightGK · SHU
Marcus BentFW · SHU
Herbert ChapmanSHU
Clayton DonaldsonFW · SHU
.jpg/330px-Billy_Sharp_2017-11-04_1_(cropped).jpg)
Billy SharpFW · SHU
Colin Kâzım-RichardsSHU
.jpg/330px-Gordon_Cowans_(portrait_1982).jpg)
Gordon CowansMF · SHU
Ian RushFW · SHU
Gary CahillSHU
Ugo EhioguSHU
Mikele LeigertwoodMF · SHU
Top all-time Sheffield United — November 2026
See the full top list →No top list yet this month — your picks and finished rankings start it.
About this tier list
A tier list sorts everyone into rows from S (the best) to F. Rename the rows, recolour them, or add your own.
181 players who played for the Sheffield Utd, greatest for the team first; search for anyone else.
Every pick and every finished ranking here counts toward the top all-time Sheffield United for November 2026.
How to use it
- Drag each tile into a tier, or tap a tile and then a row.
- Reorder tiles within a row to rank inside the tier.
- Use the sort menu and the Players bar to change who you start with.
- Missing someone? Use + Add or the search box under the board to bring in any player, team or legend.
- Download image saves a picture with your name or logo on it; Copy link shares this exact board. Your progress is kept in this browser.