Top 9 all-time MLB closers
The greatest closers in MLB history, by their honors. Pick your top 9 all-time MLB closers and number them 1 to 9 in a 3×3 grid.
Fill all 9 squares to submit your top 9 (9 left).
Save to my profile keeps it to come back to and keep ranking. Submit your ranking adds it to this month's top list.
100 to choose from · drag into a square, or tap a tile then a square
Mariano RiveraRP · NYY
Hoyt WilhelmRP · ATL
Lee SmithRP · CHC
Trevor HoffmanP/RP · SD
Goose GossageRP · NYY
Billy WagnerP/RP · HOU
Willie HernándezRP · CHC
Josh HaderRP · MIL
Jim KonstantyRP · PHI
Mike MarshallRP · WSH
Mark DavisRP · SD
Fernando RodneyRP · DET
Francisco RodríguezP/RP · LAA
José ValverdeRP · ARI
Wade DavisRP · KC
Greg HollandRP · KC
.png/330px-Tony_Oliva_Jeff_Reardon_and_1987_Twins_(cropped).png)
Jeff ReardonRP · WSH
John WettelandRP · WSH
Seth LugoRP · NYM
Brian WilsonRP · SF
Tom GordonRP · KC
Joakim SoriaRP · KC
Neftalí FelizRP · TEX
Zack BrittonRP · BAL
Brian FuentesRP · COL
Randy MyersRP · NYM
UUUgueth Urbina
RP · WSH
Andrew BaileyRP · ATH
Jim JohnsonRP · BAL
Sean DoolittleRP · ATH
Pat NeshekRP · MIN
Rafael SorianoRP · SEA
Darren O'DayRP · BAL
Mark MelanconRP · PIT
Joe NathanP/RP · MIN
Kirby YatesRP · SD
Tyler ClippardRP · WSH
Grant BalfourRP · TB
Heath BellRP · SD
Brad BrachRP · BAL
Miles MikolasRP · STL
Kelvin HerreraRP · KC
Ryan CookRP · ATH
Will HarrisRP · HOU
Brad BoxbergerRP · TB
Mike StantonRP · NYY
.jpg/330px-1986_Atlanta_Police_-_Duane_Ward_(cropped).jpg)
Duane WardRP · TOR
Alfredo SimónRP · BAL
Jonathan BroxtonRP · LAD
Sergio RomoRP · SF
Corey KnebelRP · MIL
Carlos MármolRP · CHC
_(cropped).jpg/330px-Keith_Foulke_(1866423)_(cropped).jpg)
Keith FoulkeRP · CHW
Arthur RhodesRP · BAL
J. J. PutzRP · SEA
Norm CharltonRP · CIN
Jason GrilliRP · PIT
SWScott Williamson
RP · CIN
.jpg/330px-Jos%C3%A9_Mesa_(cropped).jpg)
José MesaRP · CLE
Matt ThorntonRP · CHW
Rob DibbleRP · CIN
Brad LidgeRP · HOU
Matt CappsRP · PIT
Steve DelabarRP · TOR
Ryan PresslyRP · HOU
Kazuhiro SasakiRP · SEA
_(cropped).jpg/330px-Roberto_Hernandez_(DSCF2044)_(cropped).jpg)
Roberto HernándezRP · CHW
George SherrillRP · SEA
Jesse OroscoRP · NYM
Todd JonesRP · DET
Chris PerezRP · CLE
John FrancoRP · NYM
Chad CorderoRP · WSH
THTom Henke
RP · TOR
Daniel BardRP · BOS
JSJeff Shaw
RP · LAD
Eddie GuardadoRP · MIN
Mitch WilliamsRP · PHI
Brandon KintzlerRP · MIL
.jpg/330px-Greg_Olson_(Pitcher).jpg)
Gregg OlsonRP · BAL
Aaron CrowRP · KC
Jon RauchRP · WSH
Brian BruneyRP · NYY
Boone LoganRP · NYY
Manny DelcarmenRP · BOS
Jake McGeeRP · TB
Kevin JepsenRP · LAA
J. P. HowellRP · TB
BKBilly Koch
RP · TOR
Luis VizcaínoRP · ATH
John AxfordRP · MIL
Javier LópezRP · SF
Jason MotteRP · STL
Chris MartinRP · TEX
Ronald BelisarioRP · LAD
Cody AllenRP · CLE
Cam BedrosianRP · LAA
Scott McGoughRP · ARI
Guillermo MoscosoRP · TEX
Brad ZieglerRP · ARI
Top all-time MLB closers — November 2026
See the full top list →No top list yet this month — your picks and finished rankings start it.
What a top 9 is for
The top 9 is the classic share-a-picture format: nine picks, in order, numbered from 1.
Rank by a single question, such as most rewatched or best debut, for a top 9 that says more about your taste in players.
The greatest closers in MLB history, by their honors.
Every pick and every finished ranking here counts toward the top all-time MLB closers for November 2026.
Step by step
- Pick a size: 9, 16 or 25.
- Place each pick in its numbered square.
- Use the ✕ on a square to clear it and choose again.
- The search box under the board finds anyone else you want to add.
- Download image saves a picture of your board with your name or logo on it, and Copy link shares this exact board.