All-time MLB first basemen: keep, trade, cut
The greatest first basemen in MLB history, by their honors. Sort all-time MLB first basemen three at a time into keep, trade, cut, using each label once per round.
Labels
Ernie Banks1B · CHC
Lou Gehrig1B · NYY
Jeff Bagwell1B · HOU
KeepDrag one here
TradeDrag one here
CutDrag one here
Keep one, trade one, cut one
Top all-time MLB first basemen — November 2026
See the full top list →No top list yet this month — your picks and finished rankings start it.
How a keep, trade, cut game works
You see three at a time and give each a different label: keep, trade or cut. Each label can only go to one of them.
Deal again for a fresh set of three players whenever you like.
The greatest first basemen in MLB history, by their honors.
Every pick and every finished ranking here counts toward the top all-time MLB first basemen for November 2026.
How to make yours
- Read the three cards in front of you.
- Assign each label once.
- Press Next three to keep playing; your totals build below.
- To add someone who isn't there, search for them in the box under the board or use + Add.
- Your board stays in this browser while you work. Save it to your profile, download the picture, or share a link.