Top 9 all-time MLB first basemen
The greatest first basemen in MLB history, by their honours. Pick your top 9 all-time MLB first basemen, numbered 1 to 9.
Fill all 9 squares to submit your top 9 (9 left).
Save to my profile keeps it to come back to and keep ranking. Submit your ranking adds it to this month's top list.
100 to choose from · drag into a square, or tap a tile then a square
Ernie Banks1B · CHC
Lou Gehrig1B · NYY
Jeff Bagwell1B · HOU
David OrtizDH/1B · BOS
Mark McGwire1B · ATH
Todd HeltonQB/1B · COL
Jimmie Foxx1B · ATH
Hank Greenberg1B · DET
Dick Allen1B/3B · PHI
Jim ThomeDH/1B · CLE
Orlando Cepeda1B · SF
Harmon Killebrew1B · MIN
Eddie MurrayDH/1B · BAL
Willie McCovey1B · SF
Rod Carew1B · MIN
Freddie Freeman1B/3B · ATL
Albert PujolsP/1B · STL
Fred McGriff1B · ATL
Joey Votto1B · CIN
Cody BellingerOF/1B · LAD
Gil Hodges1B · LAD
Johnny Mize1B · STL
Ryan Howard1B · PHI
Miguel Cabrera3B/1B · DET
Josh DonaldsonC/1B · TOR
Paul Goldschmidt1B · ARI
Bryce HarperRF/1B · PHI
Tony Pérez1B · CIN
Don Mattingly1B · NYY
Cap Anson1B · CHC
Jim Bottomley1B · STL
Adrián González1B · LAD
Steve Garvey1B · LAD
Roger Connor1B · SF
_LCCN2014688319.jpg/330px-Frank_Chance%2C_Chicago%2C_NL_(baseball)_LCCN2014688319.jpg)
Frank Chance1B · CHC
George Kelly1B · CIN
Keith Hernandez1B · STL
_for_Old_Judge_Cigarettes_MET_DP846273.jpg/330px-Dennis_Joseph_%22Dan%22_Brouthers%2C_1st_Base%2C_Detroit_Wolverines%2C_from_the_Old_Judge_series_(N172)_for_Old_Judge_Cigarettes_MET_DP846273.jpg)
Dan Brouthers1B · LAD
Jason Giambi1B · ATH
José Abreu1B · CHW
Justin Morneau1B · MIN
Mo Vaughn1B · BOS
Eric Hosmer1B · KC
Anthony Rizzo1B · CHC
Michael YoungSS/1B · TEX
Mark Teixeira1B · NYY
Boog Powell1B · BAL
Phil Cavarretta1B · CHC
Charles ComiskeyP/1B · CIN
Vladimir Guerrero Jr.1B/3B · TOR
Dolph Camilli1B · LAD
Frank McCormick1B · CIN
Jake Beckley1B · CIN
Matt OlsonRF/1B · ATH
Cecil Cooper1B · MIL
Carlos Delgado1B · TOR
Prince Fielder1B · MIL
J. T. RealmutoC/1B · PHI
Rafael Palmeiro1B · TEX
Rafael DeversDH/1B · BOS
Ryan Zimmerman1B/3B · WSH
Chris Davis1B · BAL
Pete Alonso1B · NYM
Andrés Galarraga1B · WSH
Derrek Lee1B · CHC
_(cropped).jpg/330px-John_Olerud_(2919396065)_(cropped).jpg)
John Olerud1B · TOR
Carlos Peña1B · TB
Edwin EncarnaciónDH/1B · TOR
Willson ContrerasC/1B · CHC
Nick SwisherOF/1B · NYY
Carlos SantanaC/1B · CLE
Yuli Gurriel1B/2B · HOU
Adam Duvall1B · ATL
George Scott1B · BOS
Rusty StaubDH/1B · NYM
Bill Buckner1B · LAD
Paul Konerko1B · CHW
Mark TrumboLF/1B · BAL
Mitch Moreland1B · TEX
Josh BellOF/1B · PIT
Mark Grace1B · CHC
Chris Chambliss1B · ATL
Will Clark1B · SF
Cecil Fielder1B · DET
Lance Berkman1B · HOU
Steve Pearce1B · BAL
Victor Pellot1B · ATH
Wil Myers1B · SD
Brandon Belt1B · SF
Brandon Moss1B · ATH
Nate Colbert1B · SD
Mike Napoli1B · LAA
Doug Mientkiewicz1B · MIN
Dmitri Young1B · DET
Tino Martinez1B · NYY
Yonder Alonso1B · SD
Joe Adcock1B · ATL
Roy Sievers1B · MIN
Justin Smoak1B · TOR
Gerardo ParraOF/1B · ARI
Top all-time MLB first basemen — November 2026
See the full top list →No top list yet this month — your picks and finished rankings start it.
About this top 9
A numbered 3×3 of your favourites, best first. Go bigger with a top 16 or top 25.
The greatest first basemen in MLB history, by their honours.
Every pick and every finished ranking here counts toward the top all-time MLB first basemen for November 2026.
How to use it
- Drag your number one into square 1, then fill the rest in order.
- Drag one square onto another to swap them.
- Switch to 16 or 25 for a longer list.
- Missing someone? Use + Add or the search box under the board to bring in any player, team or legend.
- Download image saves a picture with your name or logo on it; Copy link shares this exact board. Your progress is kept in this browser.