TierMakerGo Ad-Free

All-time Athletics Mount Rushmore

289 players who played for the Athletics, greatest for the team first; search for anyone else. Carve your all-time Athletics Mount Rushmore.
Fill all 4 to submit (4 left).

Save to my profile keeps it to come back to and keep ranking. Submit your ranking adds it to this month's top list.

1
2
3
4
80 to choose from · drag one onto a spot, or tap it then the spot
Reggie Jackson
RF · ATH
Lefty Grove
P · ATH
Dennis Eckersley
P · ATH
Mark McGwire
1B · ATH
Jimmie Foxx
1B · ATH
Mickey Cochrane
C · ATH
Catfish Hunter
SP · ATH
Vida Blue
SP · ATH
Al Simmons
LF · ATH
Eddie Collins
2B · ATH
Rollie Fingers
P · ATH
Denny McLain
P · ATH
Miguel Tejada
SS · ATH
Nap Lajoie
2B · ATH
Eddie Plank
P · ATH
Jose Canseco
RF · ATH
Jason Giambi
1B · ATH
Rickey Henderson
LF · ATH
Bobby Shantz
P · ATH
Tony La Russa
2B · ATH
Barry Zito
P · ATH
Nellie Fox
2B · ATH
Bob Welch
SP · ATH
Josh Donaldson
C/1B · ATH
Ty Cobb
CF · ATH
George Kell
3B · ATH
Matt Olson
RF/1B · ATH
Tim Hudson
SP · ATH
Marcus Semien
SS · ATH
Frank Thomas
DH · ATH
Scott Brosius
3B · ATH
Harold Baines
RF · ATH
Eric Chavez
3B · ATH
Dave Stewart
P · ATH
Matt Chapman
3B · ATH
Enos Slaughter
RF · ATH
Whitey Herzog
OF · ATH
Walt Weiss
SS · ATH
Kurt Suzuki
C · ATH
Joe Rudi
LF · ATH
Stephen Vogt
DH/C · ATH
Jermaine Dye
RF · ATH
Sonny Gray
SP · ATH
Rick Monday
CF · ATH
Jed Lowrie
SS/3B · ATH
Willie McGee
CF · ATH
Sean Doolittle
RP · ATH
Nate Colbert
1B · ATH
Ron Darling
SP · ATH
Chris Bassitt
SP · ATH
Tony Armas
CF · ATH
Tommy Harper
LF · ATH
Dave Henderson
CF · ATH
Gio Gonzalez
SP · ATH
Dave Parker
RF · ATH
Jeff Burroughs
LF · ATH
Goose Gossage
RP · ATH
Victor Pellot
1B · ATH
Matt Keough
P · ATH
Dwayne Murphy
CF · ATH
Sal Bando
3B · ATH
Eddie Joost
SS · ATH
Paul Blackburn
P · ATH
Billy Williams
LF · ATH
Liam Hendriks
P · ATH
Ramón Hernández
C · ATH
Roger Maris
RF · ATH
Joe Morgan
2B · ATH
Don Baylor
DH · ATH
Wally Moses
RF · ATH
Yoenis Céspedes
LF · ATH
Nick Swisher
OF/1B · ATH
Mike Piazza
C · ATH
Jim Perry
P · ATH
Phil Garner
3B · ATH
Dick Allen
1B/3B · ATH
Ken Harrelson
1B · ATH
Mark Mulder
P · ATH
Bartolo Colón
P · ATH
Orlando Cepeda
1B · ATH

Top all-time Athletics — November 2026

See the full top list →

No top list yet this month — your picks and finished rankings start it.

About this Mount Rushmore

Four spots, for the four who define it. Who makes the mountain?

289 players who played for the Athletics, greatest for the team first; search for anyone else.

Every pick and every finished ranking here counts toward the top all-time Athletics for November 2026.

How to use it

  1. Click a spot to choose who goes there.
  2. Drag one face onto another to swap them.
  3. Download image saves a picture with your name or logo on it; Copy link shares this exact board. Your progress is kept in this browser.