All-time Toronto Blue Jays tier list

246 players who played for the Blue Jays, greatest for the team first; search for anyone else. Rank all-time Toronto Blue Jays from S to F.

Place at least 10 to submit your ranking (0 so far).

Save to my profile keeps it to come back to and keep ranking. Submit your ranking adds it to this month's top list.

S

A

B

C

D

E

F

Drag a tile into a tier, or tap it then tap a tier

Roy Halladay

P · TOR

Roberto Alomar

TOR

Fred McGriff

1B · TOR

George Bell

LF · TOR

Rickey Henderson

LF · TOR

Roger Clemens

P · TOR

George Springer

OF · TOR

Chris Carpenter

SP · TOR

Shawn Green

RF · TOR

Josh Donaldson

C/1B · TOR

Vladimir Guerrero Jr.

1B/3B · TOR

Carlos Delgado

1B · TOR

Paul Molitor

DH · TOR

Pat Hentgen

P · TOR

José Bautista

3B/RF · TOR

Tony Fernández

SS · TOR

Frank Thomas

DH · TOR

Vernon Wells

CF · TOR

R.A. Dickey

P · TOR

Aaron Hill

2B · TOR

John Olerud

1B · TOR

Jesse Barfield

RF · TOR

Marcus Stroman

SP · TOR

Russell Martin

C/3B · TOR

Edwin Encarnación

DH/1B · TOR

Lance Parrish

C · TOR

Kelly Gruber

3B · TOR

Michael Young

SS/1B · TOR

Alfredo Griffin

SS · TOR

Max Scherzer

SP · TOR

Rubén Sierra

LF · TOR

Kevin Gausman

P · TOR

Devon White

CF · TOR

David Wells

SP · TOR

J. A. Happ

SP · TOR

Scott Rolen

3B · TOR

Jack Morris

SP · TOR

Dámaso García

2B · TOR

Teoscar Hernández

OF · TOR

José Berríos

P · TOR

Bo Bichette

SS/2B · TOR

Alex Ríos

RF · TOR

Al Leiter

SP · TOR

Brett Cecil

SP · TOR

Lloyd Moseby

CF · TOR

Alejandro Kirk

C · TOR

Duane Ward

RP · TOR

Hyun-jin Ryu

SP · TOR

Jeff Burroughs

LF · TOR

Randy Wolf

SP · TOR

Juan Guzmán

SP · TOR

Aaron Sanchez

P · TOR

Adam Lind

1B · TOR

Jordan Romano

P · TOR

Brandon League

P · TOR

THTom Henke

RP · TOR

Lourdes Gurriel Jr.

OF · TOR

Justin Smoak

1B · TOR

Jeff Kent

2B · TOR

Travis d'Arnaud

C · TOR

Troy Tulowitzki

SS · TOR

Ernie Whitt

C · TOR

WWWoody Williams

P · TOR

Orlando Hudson

2B · TOR

Dave Winfield

DH/OF · TOR

Cecil Fielder

1B · TOR

Ricky Romero

SP · TOR

David Cone

SP · TOR

José Reyes

SS · TOR

Mike Flanagan

SP · TOR

Shane Bieber

P · TOR

Phil Niekro

SP/P · TOR

Robbie Ray

P · TOR

Ted Lilly

SP · TOR

Mark Buehrle

SP · TOR

Joey Votto

1B · TOR

Joe Carter

RF · TOR

José Cruz, Jr.

OF · TOR

Marco Estrada

SP · TOR

Troy Glaus

3B · TOR

Top all-time Toronto Blue Jays — November 2026

See the full top list →

No top list yet this month — your picks and finished rankings start it.

About this tier list

A tier list sorts everyone into rows from S (the best) to F. Rename the rows, recolour them, or add your own.

246 players who played for the Blue Jays, greatest for the team first; search for anyone else.

Every pick and every finished ranking here counts toward the top all-time Toronto Blue Jays for November 2026.

How to use it

Drag each tile into a tier, or tap a tile and then a row.
Reorder tiles within a row to rank inside the tier.
Use the sort menu and the Players bar to change who you start with.
Missing someone? Use + Add or the search box under the board to bring in any player, team or legend.
Download image saves a picture with your name or logo on it; Copy link shares this exact board. Your progress is kept in this browser.