Top 9 all-time NFL punters
The greatest punters in NFL history, by their honours. Pick your top 9 all-time NFL punters, numbered 1 to 9.
Fill all 9 squares to submit your top 9 (9 left).
Save to my profile keeps it to come back to and keep ranking. Submit your ranking adds it to this month's top list.
58 to choose from · drag into a square, or tap a tile then a square
Ray GuyP · LV
Shane LechlerP · LV
.JPG/330px-John_Lynch_(American_football).JPG)
John LynchS/P · TB
SLSean Landeta
P · NYG
John HekkerP · LAR
Brian MoormanP · BUF
JWJerrel Wilson
P · KC
DBDarren Bennett
P · LAC
.png/330px-Pat_McAfee_on_The_Pat_McAfee_Show_8.31.2022_(cropped).png)
Pat McAfeeFW/P · IND
RRReggie Roby
P · MIA
Michael DicksonP · SEA
.JPG/330px-Andy_Lee_(American_football).JPG)
Andy LeeP · SF
Jeff FeaglesP · NYG
Brett KernP · TEN
Thomas MorsteadP · NO
Ron WidbyP · DAL
Jake BaileyP · NE
Mitch BergerP · PIT
Chris HansonP · JAX
Logan CookeP · JAX
A. J. Cole IIIP · LV
JJJohn James
P · ATL
TTTom Tupa
P · ARI
Chris GardockiP · PIT
Jeff GossettP · CLE
Mat McBriarP · DAL
.jpg/330px-Josh_Bidwell_(cropped).jpg)
Josh BidwellP · TB
Craig HentrichP · GB
Bryan AngerP · DAL
RTRick Tuten
P · SEA
MHMike Horan
P · DEN
JAJim Arnold
P · DET
Matt TurkP · LAR
DHDale Hatcher
P · LAR
Tommy TownsendP · KC
BBBryan Barker
P · JAX
.png/330px-Chiefs_Punter_Dustin_Colquitt_Super_Bowl_54_Interview_(cropped).png)
Dustin ColquittP · KC
TSTodd Sauerbrun
P · CAR
PMPat McInally
P · CIN
BGBob Grupp
P · KC
SPScott Player
P · NYJ
Ryan AllenP · NE
Britton ColquittP · DEN
Donnie JonesP · PHI
Jon RyanP · SEA
Chris KluweP · MIN
.jpg/330px-Kevin_Huber_2021_(cropped).jpg)
Kevin HuberP · CIN
KRKyle Richardson
P · BAL
Adam PodleshP · CHI
Tim MasthayP · GB
Hunter SmithP · IND
CCCraig Colquitt
P · PIT
Josh MillerP · TEN
TRTom Rouen
P · DEN
Jason BakerP · CAR
.jpg/330px-Brad_Maynard_(Chicago_Bears_training_camp%2C_2009).jpg)
Brad MaynardP · CHI
Robert MaloneP · JAX
Sam KochP · BAL
Top all-time NFL punters — November 2026
See the full top list →No top list yet this month — your picks and finished rankings start it.
About this top 9
A numbered 3×3 of your favourites, best first. Go bigger with a top 16 or top 25.
The greatest punters in NFL history, by their honours.
Every pick and every finished ranking here counts toward the top all-time NFL punters for November 2026.
How to use it
- Drag your number one into square 1, then fill the rest in order.
- Drag one square onto another to swap them.
- Switch to 16 or 25 for a longer list.
- Missing someone? Use + Add or the search box under the board to bring in any player, team or legend.
- Download image saves a picture with your name or logo on it; Copy link shares this exact board. Your progress is kept in this browser.