All-time New York Giants tier list

206 players who played for the Giants, greatest for the team first; search for anyone else. Make your own all-time New York Giants tier list with rows you can rename, recolor or split into columns.
Place at least 10 to submit your ranking (0 so far).

Save to my profile keeps it to come back to and keep ranking. Submit your ranking adds it to this month's top list.

S
A
B
C
D
E
F
Drag a tile into a tier, or tap it then tap a tier
Michael Strahan
DE · NYG
Lawrence Taylor
LB · NYG
Fran Tarkenton
QB · NYG
Mel Hein
C · NYG
Tom Landry
CB · NYG
Sam Huff
LB · NYG
Cal Hubbard
NYG
Jim Thorpe
RB/OF · NYG
Emlen Tunnell
NYG
Rosey Brown
OT · NYG
Eli Manning
QB · NYG
Saquon Barkley
RB · NYG
Y. A. Tittle
QB · NYG
Larry Csonka
RB · NYG
Phil Simms
QB · NYG
Carl Banks
LB · NYG
Tuffy Leemans
NYG
KSKen Strong
NYG
PHPete Henry
OT · NYG
Joe Guyon
OT · NYG
George Connor
LB · NYG
Arnie Herber
QB · NYG
Frank Gifford
S/RB · NYG
SOSteve Owen
OT · NYG
Odell Beckham Jr.
WR · NYG
Harry Carson
LB · NYG
Hugh McElhenny
NYG
Ray Flaherty
END · NYG
Dexter Lawrence
DT · NYG
Benny Friedman
QB · NYG
Red Badgro
WR · NYG
Tiki Barber
RB · NYG
ARAndy Robustelli
DE · NYG
Arnie Weinmeister
DT · NYG
Jeremy Shockey
TE · NYG
Jason Pierre-​Paul
DE · NYG
David Tyree
WR · NYG
Graham Gano
K · NYG
Victor Cruz
WR · NYG
SLSean Landeta
P · NYG
Kurt Warner
QB · NYG
Antonio Pierce
LB · NYG
Leonard Williams
DE · NYG
Morten Andersen
K · NYG
Evan Engram
TE · NYG
Earl Morrall
QB · NYG
Landon Collins
S · NYG
Fred Dryer
DE · NYG
Kerry Collins
QB · NYG
Ottis Anderson
RB · NYG
Julian Love
CB · NYG
Dominique Rodgers-​Cromartie
CB · NYG
FCFrank Cope
NYG
Brian Burns
LB · NYG
David Diehl
NYG
Don Maynard
WR · NYG
Shayne Graham
K · NYG
Jeff Feagles
P · NYG
Jeff Hostetler
QB · NYG
BEBill Edwards
C · NYG
Len Younce
NYG
Al Blozis
OT · NYG
Justin Tuck
DE · NYG
Osi Umenyiora
DE · NYG
Matt Bryant
K · NYG
Antrel Rolle
S · NYG
Ed McCaffrey
WR · NYG
Olivier Vernon
DE · NYG
Cameron Wake
DE · NYG
Zak DeOssie
NYG
MHMark Haynes
CB · NYG
Janoris Jenkins
CB · NYG
Michael Thomas
S · NYG
Linval Joseph
NYG
Pepper Johnson
LB · NYG
Shaun O'Hara
C · NYG
Frank Winters
C · NYG
Sam Madison
CB · NYG
BOBart Oates
C · NYG
Chris Snee
NYG

Top all-time New York Giants — November 2026

See the full top list →

No top list yet this month — your picks and finished rankings start it.

How a tier list works

A tier list groups everything into rows from S, the best, down to F. You can rename the rows, change their colors, add more or take some away.

Start from the classic S to F rows, or reset them any time from the Customize menu.

206 players who played for the Giants, greatest for the team first; search for anyone else.

Every pick and every finished ranking here counts toward the top all-time New York Giants for November 2026.

How to make yours

  1. Drag each tile into a tier, or tap a tile and then tap a row.
  2. Move tiles within a row to rank inside the tier.
  3. Open a row's settings to rename it, recolor it or add a row next to it.
  4. Use the bar above the board to switch to another group, such as stars, one position or Hall of Famers.
  5. To add someone who isn't there, search for them in the box under the board or use + Add.
  6. Your board stays in this browser while you work. Save it to your profile, download the picture, or share a link.