Top 9 all-time New York Islanders
196 players who played for the Islanders, greatest for the team first; search for anyone else. Pick your top 9 all-time New York Islanders and number them 1 to 9 in a 3×3 grid.
Fill all 9 squares to submit your top 9 (9 left).
Save to my profile keeps it to come back to and keep ranking. Submit your ranking adds it to this month's top list.
80 to choose from · drag into a square, or tap a tile then a square
Billy SmithG · NYI
Bryan TrottierNYI
CGClark Gillies
NYI
Zdeno CháraD · NYI
Mike BossyNYI
Denis PotvinD · NYI
Pat LaFontaineC · NYI
Frans NielsenNYI
John TavaresFW/C · NYI
Leo KomarovC · NYI
Kyle OkposoNYI
Jason BlakeNYI
Josh BaileyFW · NYI
Bo HorvatC · NYI
Mathew BarzalC · NYI
.jpg/330px-Ron_Hextall_(Philadelphia_Flyers_GM).jpg)
Ron HextallG · NYI
Nick LeddyD · NYI
Bill TorreyNYI
Travis HamonicD · NYI
Johnny BoychukD · NYI
Jaroslav HalákG · NYI
Roman HamrlíkD · NYI
Mark ParrishNYI
Billy MacMillanC · NYI
Butch GoringFW · NYI
Evgeni NabokovG · NYI
Doug WeightC · NYI
.jpg/330px-Trevor_Linden's_GOAL!_(2110489067).jpg)
Trevor LindenC · NYI
Miroslav ŠatanNYI
Žigmund PálffyNYI
Andrew LaddNYI
.jpg/330px-Martin_Straka_2013-04-24_(cropped).jpg)
Martin StrakaC · NYI
AZAlexei Zhitnik
D · NYI
Ľubomír VišňovskýD · NYI
Todd BertuzziNYI
Alexei YashinC · NYI
Mariusz CzerkawskiNYI
Janne NiinimaaD · NYI
Michael PecaC · NYI
Bryan McCabeD · NYI
.jpg/330px-Josef_Va%C5%A1%C3%AD%C4%8Dek_(hrob).jpg)
Josef VašíčekC · NYI
Tomas JonssonD · NYI
Robert ReichelFW · NYI
Adrian AucoinD · NYI
Wendel ClarkNYI
Chico ReschG · NYI
.JPG/330px-Vladimir_Malakhov_(hockey).JPG)
Vladimir MalakhovD · NYI
Tim ThomasG · NYI
HMHector Marini
NYI
Mike DunhamG · NYI
SNSergei Nemchinov
C · NYI
Ken MorrowD · NYI
Chris SimonNYI
FPFélix Potvin
G · NYI
Ed WestfallNYI
Semyon VarlamovG · NYI
Brock NelsonFW/C · NYI
Eric BrewerD · NYI
Tom FitzgeraldNYI
Todd McLellanFW · NYI
Raimo HelminenC · NYI
Cory SchneiderG · NYI
Zach PariseNYI
SHSean Hill
D · NYI
Ron StewartC · NYI
Brent SutterC · NYI
Dave LewisD · NYI
Bob NystromNYI
Anders LeeFW/C · NYI
SLScott Lachance
D · NYI
Brayden SchennC · NYI
Roland MelansonG · NYI
TCTom Chorske
NYI
GGGreg Gilbert
NYI
Craig LudwigD · NYI
Glenn HealyG · NYI
Tyler KennedyC · NYI
AKAnders Kallur
FW · NYI
Kyle PalmieriC · NYI
Jean-Gabriel PageauC · NYI
Top all-time New York Islanders — November 2026
See the full top list →No top list yet this month — your picks and finished rankings start it.
How a top 9 works
A top 9 is a numbered 3×3 grid of favorites. Square 1 holds your best, and the numbers run across each row.
Swap two squares by dragging one onto the other.
196 players who played for the Islanders, greatest for the team first; search for anyone else.
Every pick and every finished ranking here counts toward the top all-time New York Islanders for November 2026.
How to make yours
- Pick a size: 9, 16 or 25.
- Place each pick in its numbered square.
- Use the ✕ on a square to clear it and choose again.
- To add someone who isn't there, search for them in the box under the board or use + Add.
- Your board stays in this browser while you work. Save it to your profile, download the picture, or share a link.