All-time Toronto Maple Leafs Mount Rushmore

294 players who played for the Maple Leafs, greatest for the team first; search for anyone else. Choose the four all-time Toronto Maple Leafs who belong on your Mount Rushmore.
Fill all 4 to submit (4 left).

Save to my profile keeps it to come back to and keep ranking. Submit your ranking adds it to this month's top list.

1
2
3
4
80 to choose from · drag one onto a spot, or tap it then the spot
Jacques Plante
G · TOR
Börje Salming
D · TOR
Auston Matthews
C · TOR
Brian Leetch
D · TOR
Bernie Parent
G · TOR
Leo Boivin
D · TOR
Ed Belfour
G · TOR
Eric Lindros
C · TOR
Terry Sawchuk
GK/G · TOR
Joe Nieuwendyk
C · TOR
Red Kelly
D/C · TOR
Grant Fuhr
G · TOR
Dave Andreychuk
TOR
Andy Bathgate
C · TOR
Frank Nighbor
C · TOR
Pierre Pilote
D · TOR
Ron Francis
C · TOR
Dave Keon
C · TOR
MBMax Bentley
C · TOR
George Hainsworth
G · TOR
Dickie Moore
TOR
Ted Kennedy
C · TOR
Johnny Bower
G · TOR
Mats Sundin
C · TOR
Babe Pratt
D · TOR
Turk Broda
G · TOR
Doug Gilmour
FW · TOR
Phil Kessel
TOR
Lanny McDonald
TOR
Phil Housley
D · TOR
John Tavares
FW/C · TOR
Mitchell Marner
FW · TOR
Tomáš Kaberle
D · TOR
Larry Murphy
D · TOR
Mike Gartner
TOR
HLHarry Lumley
G · TOR
Darryl Sittler
C · TOR
Frank Mahovlich
TOR
Al Arbour
D · TOR
Glenn Anderson
TOR
Pat Quinn
D · TOR
Tim Horton
D · TOR
Syl Apps
C · TOR
Marcel Pronovost
D · TOR
Bud Poile
FW · TOR
Allan Stanley
D · TOR
Ace Bailey
TOR
Bob Pulford
FW · TOR
Ricardo Andrés Vega Torres
D · TOR
Bert Olmstead
TOR
King Clancy
D · TOR
Bryan McCabe
D · TOR
Gerry Cheevers
G · TOR
Babe Dye
TOR
Syd Howe
TOR
Hap Day
D · TOR
Sweeney Schriner
TOR
Jim Rutherford
G · TOR
Charlie Conacher
TOR
Carl Voss
C · TOR
Dick Duff
TOR
Busher Jackson
TOR
Norm Ullman
C · TOR
Harry Watson
TOR
Joe Primeau
C · TOR
ARAl Rollins
G · TOR
Frederik Andersen
G · TOR
Gordie Drillon
TOR
Red Horner
D · TOR
Frank Foyston
FW · TOR
Frank Mathers
D · TOR
Tom Barrasso
G · TOR
Bob Nevin
TOR
Larry Hillman
D · TOR
RERon Ellis
TOR
George Armstrong
C · TOR
Mark Giordano
D · TOR
Jake Muzzin
D · TOR
Randy Carlyle
D · TOR
Alexander Mogilny
TOR

Top all-time Toronto Maple Leafs — November 2026

See the full top list →

No top list yet this month — your picks and finished rankings start it.

What a Mount Rushmore is for

The four faces are carved into the mountain in order, first to fourth, each with a name plate below.

Make one for a single era or team, and another for all time, to see how your four players change.

294 players who played for the Maple Leafs, greatest for the team first; search for anyone else.

Every pick and every finished ranking here counts toward the top all-time Toronto Maple Leafs for November 2026.

Step by step

  1. Fill the four spots from first to fourth.
  2. Use the ✕ on a face to clear it and choose again.
  3. The search box under the board finds anyone else you want to add.
  4. Download image saves a picture of your board with your name or logo on it, and Copy link shares this exact board.