MLB first basemen face-off
Every current MLB first basemen, best known first. Set two sides of MLB first basemen against each other and decide who takes each row, or call it even.
Drag pictures onto both sides of a row to make a matchup
0–00 even
49 not in a matchup · drag one onto either side of a row (up to 4 a side)
Freddie Freeman#51B · LAD
Bryce Harper#31B · PHI
Kris Bryant#23DH · COL
Vladimir Guerrero Jr.#271B · TOR
Matt Olson#281B · ATL
Rafael Devers#161B · SF
Pete Alonso#251B · BAL
Willson Contreras#401B · BOS
Jorge Polanco#11DH · NYM
Christian Walker#81B · HOU
Jose Fernandez#11DH · ARI
Josh Naylor#121B · SEA
Nick Kurtz#161B · ATH
Jonathan Aranda#81B · TB
Munetaka Murakami#51B · CHW
Jake Burger#211B · TEX
Tim Tawa#131B · ARI
Tyler Locklear#311B · ARI
Tommy White#471B · ATH
Triston Casas#361B · BOS
Michael Busch#291B · CHC
Tanner Murray#41LF · CHW
Spencer Steer#71B · CIN
Kyle Manzardo#91B · CLE
Jose Tena#8DH · CLE
TJ Rumfield#71B · COL
Troy Johnston#20RF · COL
Spencer Torkelson#201B · DET
Jace Jung#173B · DET
Colt Keith#333B · DET
Vinnie Pasquantino#91B · KC
Nolan Schanuel#181B · LAA
Vaughn Grissom#51B · LAA
Griffin Conine#18RF · MIA
Deyvison De Los Santos#631B · MIA
Andrew Vaughn#281B · MIL
Royce Lewis#231B · MIN
Jared Young#291B · NYM
Luis Garcia Jr.#261B · NYY
Felix Reyes#29LF · PHI
Spencer Horwitz#21B · PIT
Gavin Sheets#301B · SD
Michael Toglia#481B · SEA
Victor Bericoto#78LF · SF
Alec Burleson#411B · STL
Jose Fermin#15LF · STL
Charles McAdoo#262B · TOR
Abimelec Ortiz#811B · WSH
Yohandy Morales#281B · WSH
Top MLB first basemen — November 2026
See the full top list →- 1Bryce Harper
- 2Vladimir Guerrero Jr.
- 3Willson Contreras
- 4Jorge Polanco
- 5Christian Walker
About this face-off
The score at the top counts the rows each side took and the ones you called even.
Save your face-off and share it: anyone who opens it can call the same matchups their own way.
Every current MLB first basemen, best known first.
Every pick and every finished ranking here counts toward the top MLB first basemen for November 2026.
How to use it
- Deal a random set of matchups, or clear the board and drag pictures onto either side of each row.
- Tap the better side of each row, or the = in the middle when they're even.
- Download the picture or save it so others can call the same matchups.
- If someone is missing, use + Add or the search box under the board to bring them in.
- When you're done, download the picture or copy a link that opens your board as you left it.