All-time MLB players face-off
The 100 greatest players in MLB history, by Hall of Fame, all-time teams, MVPs and All-Star selections; search for anyone else who played in it. Pit all-time MLB players against each other row by row, one on one or in twos and threes, and keep score.
Drag pictures onto both sides of a row to make a matchup
0–00 even
100 not in a matchup · drag one onto either side of a row (up to 4 a side)
Sandy KoufaxP · LAD
.jpg/330px-Ken_Griffey%2C_Jr._June_2009_(cropped).jpg)
Ken Griffey Jr.CF · SEA
Hank AaronRF/OF · ATL
Jackie Robinson2B · LAD
Mickey MantleCF · NYY
Willie MaysCF · SF
Joe DiMaggioCF · NYY
Mike Schmidt3B · PHI
Brooks Robinson3B · BAL
Yogi BerraC · NYY
Reggie JacksonRF · ATH
Cal Ripken Jr.SS · BAL
Ted WilliamsLF · BOS
Ernie Banks1B · CHC
Lou Gehrig1B · NYY
Babe RuthP/OF · NYY
Frank RobinsonLF · CIN
Roger ClemensP · BOS
Warren SpahnP/SP · ATL
Joe MauerDH/C · MIN
Lefty GroveP · ATH
Nolan RyanP · HOU
Johnny BenchC · CIN
Ichiro SuzukiOF · SEA
Ty CobbCF · DET
Rollie FingersP · ATH
Randy JohnsonP · SEA
Cy YoungP · BOS
Jeff Bagwell1B · HOU
Pete RoseLF · CIN
Derek JeterSS · NYY
Dennis EckersleyP · ATH
David OrtizDH/1B · BOS
Roy HalladayP · TOR
Vladimir GuerreroDH/RF · WSH
Christy MathewsonP · SF
Walter JohnsonP · MIN
Shohei OhtaniP/DH · LAA
Mark McGwire1B · ATH
_MET_DPB881959.jpg/330px-Rogers_Hornsby%2C_2_B_-_St._Louis_N.%2C_from_Baseball_strip_cards_(W575-2)_MET_DPB881959.jpg)
Rogers Hornsby2B · STL
Pedro MartinezSP · BOS
Frank ThomasDH · CHW
Joe Morgan2B · HOU
Barry LarkinSS · CIN
Carl YastrzemskiLF · BOS
Rickey HendersonLF · ATH
Iván RodríguezC · TEX
Chipper Jones3B · ATL
Joe TorreC · ATL
Ryne Sandberg2B · CHC
.jpg/330px-Andre_Dawson_in_the_Cubs_dugout_(cropped).jpg)
Andre DawsonCF · CLE
Mariano RiveraRP · NYY
Greg MadduxP · ATL
Tom GlavineP · ATL
Clayton KershawSP · LAD
George Brett3B · KC
Whitey FordSP · NYY
Robin YountSS · MIL
Jim RiceDH/LF · BOS
Todd HeltonQB/1B · COL
_(cropped).jpg/330px-Mike_Piazza_(1999)_(cropped).jpg)
Mike PiazzaC · NYM
Jimmie Foxx1B · ATH
Jim PalmerSP · BAL
John SmoltzP/SP · ATL
Jeff Kent2B · SF
Hank Greenberg1B · DET
Tom SeaverSP · NYM
Steve CarltonP · PHI
Dick Allen1B/3B · PHI
Nellie Fox2B · CHW
Jim ThomeDH/1B · CLE
Gaylord PerrySP · SF
Orlando Cepeda1B · SF
Phil RizzutoSS · NYY
CC SabathiaP · NYY
Barry BondsLF · SF
Gary CarterC · WSH
Ferguson JenkinsSP · CHC
Harmon Killebrew1B · MIN
Justin VerlanderSP · DET
Dizzy DeanP · STL
Lou BoudreauSS · CLE
Dave WinfieldDH/OF · NYY
Hal NewhouserP · DET
Carl HubbellSP · SF
Eddie MurrayDH/1B · BAL
Mickey CochraneC · ATH
Willie McCovey1B · SF
Rod Carew1B · MIN
Tony GwynnOF/RF · SD
.jpg/330px-Joe_Gordon_1942_(2).jpg)
Joe Gordon2B · NYY
Gabby HartnettC · CHC
Charlie Gehringer2B · DET
Andruw JonesDH/CF · ATL
Catfish HunterSP · ATH
Freddie Freeman1B/3B · ATL
Bruce SutterP · CHC
Chuck KleinRF · PHI
.jpg/330px-Roberto_Alomar_(cropped).jpg)
Roberto AlomarTOR
Albert PujolsP/1B · STL
Top all-time MLB players — November 2026
See the full top list →- 1Willie Mays
- 2Ernie Banks
- 3Mike Schmidt
- 4Hank Aaron
- 5Babe Ruth
About this face-off
The score at the top counts the rows each side took and the ones you called even.
Save your face-off and share it: anyone who opens it can call the same matchups their own way.
The 100 greatest players in MLB history, by Hall of Fame, all-time teams, MVPs and All-Star selections; search for anyone else who played in it.
Every pick and every finished ranking here counts toward the top all-time MLB players for November 2026.
How to use it
- Deal a random set of matchups, or clear the board and drag pictures onto either side of each row.
- Tap the better side of each row, or the = in the middle when they're even.
- Download the picture or save it so others can call the same matchups.
- If someone is missing, use + Add or the search box under the board to bring them in.
- When you're done, download the picture or copy a link that opens your board as you left it.