All-time MLB catchers bracket

The greatest catchers in MLB history, by their honours. Fill out a all-time MLB catchers bracket.

PlaySize

Pick a champion to submit your bracket.

Save to my profile keeps it to come back to and keep ranking. Submit your ranking adds it to this month's top list.

Tap the winner of each match · 15 matches left

Round of 16

Quarterfinals

Semifinals

Final

Seeds

Drag to reorder (or tap one, then tap where it goes). The top 16 are in. Changing seeds keeps the picks that still fit.

1

Yogi Berra1946–1965

2

Joe Mauer2004–2018

3

Johnny Bench

4

Iván Rodríguez1991–2011

5

Joe Torre1960–1977

6

Mike Piazza1992–2007

7

Gary Carter1974–1992

8

Mickey Cochrane1925–1937

9

Gabby Hartnett1922–1940

10

Roy Campanella

11

Buster Posey2009–2021

12

Carlton Fisk1969–1993

13

Craig Biggio1988–2007

14

Ernie Lombardi

15

Ted Simmons

16

Josh Donaldson2010–2023

–

Rick Ferrell1929–1947

–

Buck Ewing1880–1897

–

Thurman Munson1969–1979

–

Salvador Pérez2011–2026

–

Elston Howard

–

Branch Rickey1905–1914

–

Russell Martin2006–2019

–

Bill Dickey

–

Al Lopez

–

Ray Schalk

–

Roger Bresnahan

–

J. T. Realmuto2014–2026

–

Jason Varitek1997–2011

–

Bob Boone1972–1990

–

Kyle Schwarber2015–2026

–

Brian McCann2005–2019

–

Wilson Ramos2010–2021

–

Gary Sánchez2015–2026

–

Willson Contreras2016–2026

–

Benito Santiago1986–2005

–

Lance Parrish1977–1988

–

A. J. Pierzynski1998–2016

–

Yan Gomes2012–2024

–

Carlos Santana2010–2026

–

Matt Wieters2007–2020

–

Adley Rutschman2022–2026

–

Dave Nilsson1992–1999

–

Bill Freehan1961–1976

–

Travis d'Arnaud2007–2026

–

Darrell Porter

–

Brad Ausmus1993–2010

–

Darren Daulton1983–1997

–

Gene Conley1952–1963

–

Joe Girardi1989–2003

–

Kurt Suzuki2007–2022

–

Stephen Vogt2012–2022

–

Alex Avila2009–2021

–

Will Smith2019–2026

–

Pat Borders

–

Cal Raleigh2021–2026

–

Ray Fosse1967–1975

–

Del Crandall1949–1963

–

Charles Johnson1994–2005

–

Jim Sundberg

–

Tony Peña2006–2011

–

Martín Maldonado2011–2025

–

John Roseboro

–

Bengie Molina1998–2010

–

Terry Kennedy1978–1991

–

Ramón Hernández1994–2014

–

Mike Scioscia1980–1992

–

Jonathan Lucroy2010–2021

–

Alvin Dark1946–1960

–

Jason Castro2010–2022

–

Yasmani Grandal2012–2024

–

Sean Murphy2019–2026

–

Sherm Lollar1946–1963

–

Sandy Alomar, Jr.

–

Javy López1992–2006

–

Tucker Barnhart2014–2025

–

Geovany Soto2005–2017

–

Derek Norris2012–2018

–

Miguel Montero2006–2018

–

Mike Matheny

–

Carlos Ruiz2006–2017

–

Mike Zunino2013–2023

–

Elías Díaz2015–2026

–

Alejandro Kirk2020–2026

–

Rick Dempsey1969–1992

–

Steve Yeager1972–1986

–

BD

Bo Díaz1977–1989

–

Jason Kendall1996–2010

–

James McCann2014–2026

–

Dioner Navarro2000–2019

–

Tim McCarver1959–1980

–

Mitch Garver2017–2026

–

Mike Sweeney1995–2010

–

John Buck1998–2015

–

Devin Mesoraco2011–2019

–

Earl Battey

–

Randy Hundley1964–1965

–

Jody Davis1981–1990

–

Terry Steinbach

–

DM

Damian Miller1997–2007

Top all-time MLB catchers — November 2026

See the full top list →

No top list yet this month — your picks and finished rankings start it.

About this bracket

A knockout bracket: pick the winner of every matchup, round by round, until one is left.

The greatest catchers in MLB history, by their honours.

Every pick and every finished ranking here counts toward the top all-time MLB catchers for November 2026.

How to use it

Choose a size, from 4 to 64.
Click the winner of each matchup to move them on.
Change a pick at any time; later rounds update.
Download image saves a picture with your name or logo on it; Copy link shares this exact board. Your progress is kept in this browser.

Other MLB positions

Starting pitchers Closers First basemen Second basemen Third basemen Shortstops Outfielders Designated hitters