All-time MLB catchers Mount Rushmore
The greatest catchers in MLB history, by their honours. Carve your all-time MLB catchers Mount Rushmore.
Fill all 4 to submit (4 left).
Save to my profile keeps it to come back to and keep ranking. Submit your ranking adds it to this month's top list.
1
2
3
4
100 to choose from · drag one onto a spot, or tap it then the spot
Yogi BerraC · NYY
Joe MauerDH/C · MIN
Johnny BenchC · CIN
Iván RodríguezC · TEX
Joe TorreC · ATL
_(cropped).jpg/330px-Mike_Piazza_(1999)_(cropped).jpg)
Mike PiazzaC · NYM
Gary CarterC · WSH
Mickey CochraneC · ATH
Gabby HartnettC · CHC
.jpg/330px-Roy_Campanella_1953_(2).jpg)
Roy CampanellaC · LAD
Buster PoseyC · SF
Carlton FiskC · CHW
Craig BiggioC/OF · HOU
Ernie LombardiC · CIN
Ted SimmonsC · MIL
Josh DonaldsonC/1B · TOR
Rick FerrellC · BAL
Buck EwingC · SF
Thurman MunsonC · NYY
Salvador PérezC · KC
Elston HowardC · NYY
_LCCN2014694638.jpg/330px-Branch_Rickey%2C_St._Louis_AL_(baseball)_LCCN2014694638.jpg)
Branch RickeyC · BAL
Russell MartinC/3B · LAD
Bill DickeyC · NYY
Al LopezC · CLE
Ray SchalkC · CHW
_vs._Pittsburgh_Pirates_(NL)_baseball_game_in_1908_with_an_umpire_and_batter_(cropped).jpg/330px-Roger_Bresnahan_catching_at_a_York_Giants_(NL)_vs._Pittsburgh_Pirates_(NL)_baseball_game_in_1908_with_an_umpire_and_batter_(cropped).jpg)
Roger BresnahanC · CHC
J. T. RealmutoC/1B · PHI
Jason VaritekC · BOS
Bob BooneC · PHI
Kyle SchwarberDH/C · CHC
Brian McCannC · ATL
Wilson RamosC · WSH
Gary SánchezC · NYY
Willson ContrerasC/1B · CHC
.jpg/330px-Benito_Santiago_at_Joe_Robbie_Stadium_(cropped).jpg)
Benito SantiagoC · SD
Lance ParrishC · DET
A. J. PierzynskiC · CHW
Yan GomesC · CLE
Carlos SantanaC/1B · CLE
Matt WietersC · BAL
Adley RutschmanC · BAL
Dave NilssonC · MIL
Bill FreehanC · DET
Travis d'ArnaudC · NYM
Darrell PorterC · MIL
Brad AusmusC · HOU
Darren DaultonC · PHI
.JPG/330px-Gene_Conley_1960_(cropped).JPG)
Gene ConleyC · ATL
Joe GirardiC · CHC
Kurt SuzukiC · ATH
Stephen VogtDH/C · ATH
Alex AvilaC · DET
Will SmithC · LAD
Pat BordersC · TOR
Cal RaleighDH/C · SEA
Ray FosseC · ATH
Del CrandallC · ATL
_(cropped).jpg/330px-Charles_Johnson_(28974422378)_(cropped).jpg)
Charles JohnsonC · MIA
_(cropped).jpg/330px-Jim_Sundberg_(5555075122)_(cropped).jpg)
Jim SundbergC · TEX
Tony PeñaC · ARI
Martín MaldonadoC · HOU
John RoseboroC · LAD
Bengie MolinaC · LAA
Terry KennedyC · SD
Ramón HernándezC · ATH
Mike SciosciaC · LAD
Jonathan LucroyC · MIL
Alvin DarkC · SF
Jason CastroC · HOU
Yasmani GrandalC · LAD
Sean MurphyC · ATH
Sherm LollarC · CHW
Sandy Alomar, Jr.C · CLE
Javy LópezC · ATL
Tucker BarnhartC · CIN
Geovany SotoC · CHC
Derek NorrisC · ATH
Miguel MonteroC · ARI
Mike MathenyC · MIL
Carlos RuizC · PHI
Mike ZuninoC · SEA
Elías DíazC · PIT
Alejandro KirkC · TOR
Rick DempseyC · BAL
Steve YeagerC · LAD
BDBo Díaz
C · CIN
Jason KendallC · PIT
James McCannC · DET
Dioner NavarroC · TB
Tim McCarverC · STL
Mitch GarverC · MIN
.jpg/330px-Carlos_Correa_meets_Royals_legend_Mike_Sweeney_(22815623446).jpg)
Mike SweeneyC · KC
John BuckC · HOU
Devin MesoracoC · CIN
Earl BatteyC · CHW
Randy HundleyC · MIN
Jody DavisC · CHC
Terry SteinbachC · ATH
DMDamian Miller
C · ARI
Top all-time MLB catchers — November 2026
See the full top list →No top list yet this month — your picks and finished rankings start it.
About this Mount Rushmore
Four spots, for the four who define it. Who makes the mountain?
The greatest catchers in MLB history, by their honours.
Every pick and every finished ranking here counts toward the top all-time MLB catchers for November 2026.
How to use it
- Click a spot to choose who goes there.
- Drag one face onto another to swap them.
- Download image saves a picture with your name or logo on it; Copy link shares this exact board. Your progress is kept in this browser.