Hall of Fame MLB starting pitchers tier list
MLB starting pitchers in the Hall of Fame, greatest first. Rank hall of Fame MLB starting pitchers from S to F.
Place at least 10 to submit your ranking (0 so far).
Save to my profile keeps it to come back to and keep ranking. Submit your ranking adds it to this month's top list.
S
A
B
C
D
E
F
Drag a tile into a tier, or tap it then tap a tier
Sandy KoufaxP · LAD
Babe RuthP/OF · NYY
Warren SpahnP/SP · ATL
Lefty GroveP · ATH
Nolan RyanP · HOU
Rollie FingersP · ATH
Randy JohnsonP · SEA
Cy YoungP · BOS
Dennis EckersleyP · ATH
Roy HalladayP · TOR
Christy MathewsonP · SF
Walter JohnsonP · MIN
Pedro MartinezSP · BOS
Greg MadduxP · ATL
Tom GlavineP · ATL
Whitey FordSP · NYY
Jim PalmerSP · BAL
John SmoltzP/SP · ATL
Tom SeaverSP · NYM
Steve CarltonP · PHI
Gaylord PerrySP · SF
CC SabathiaP · NYY
Ferguson JenkinsSP · CHC
Dizzy DeanP · STL
Hal NewhouserP · DET
Carl HubbellSP · SF
Catfish HunterSP · ATH
Bruce SutterP · CHC
Early WynnSP · CLE
Jim BunningP · DET
Phil NiekroSP/P · ATL
.jpg/330px-12447v_Satchel_Paige_seated_in_front_of_a_portrait_of_himself_in_a_baseball_uniform_(cropped).jpg)
Satchel PaigeP · BAL
Jack MorrisSP · DET
Mike MussinaSP · BAL
Don DrysdaleP · LAD
Lefty GomezP · NYY
Jim KaatP · MIN
Bert BlylevenP · MIN
Ted LyonsP · CHW
Bob FellerSP · CLE
Trevor HoffmanP/RP · SD
Billy WagnerP/RP · HOU
Don SuttonSP · LAD
Robin RobertsSP · PHI
Juan MarichalSP · SF
Red RuffingP · NYY
Bob LemonP · CLE
Grover Cleveland AlexanderP · CHC
Stan CoveleskiP · CLE
Burleigh GrimesP · NYY
Chief BenderP · CHW
_for_Old_Judge_Cigarettes_MET_DP825928.jpg/330px-Timothy_John_Tim_Keefe%2C_Pitcher%2C_New_York%2C_from_the_Old_Judge_series_(N172)_for_Old_Judge_Cigarettes_MET_DP825928.jpg)
Tim KeefeSP · SF
Herb PennockP · BOS
Waite HoytP · NYY
.jpg/330px-Former_professional_baseball_player_Dazzy_Vance_duck_hunting_in_Crystal_River_(15245079568).jpg)
Dazzy VanceP · LAD
Red FaberP · CHW
Mickey WelchP · SF
Eppa RixeyP · CIN
Eddie PlankP · ATH
Jack ChesbroP · NYY
Jesse HainesP · CIN
Tommy LasordaP · LAD
)_LOC_2162688797.jpg/330px-(Clark_Griffith%2C_Cincinnati%2C_NL_(baseball))_LOC_2162688797.jpg)
Clark Calvin GriffithP · CIN
Amos RusieP · SF
Albert SpaldingP · CHC
Ed WalshP · CHW
Charles ComiskeyP/1B · CIN
John ClarksonSP · CHC
Cristiano RonaldoP · CHC
Kid NicholsP · PHI
Joe McCarthyP · CHC
Rube MarquardP · CIN
Joe McGinnityP · SF
_LCCN2014686449.jpg/330px-Hank_O'Day%2C_umpire_(baseball)_LCCN2014686449.jpg)
Hank O'DayP · SF
Top hall of Fame MLB starting pitchers — November 2026
See the full top list →No top list yet this month — your picks and finished rankings start it.
About this tier list
A tier list sorts everyone into rows from S (the best) to F. Rename the rows, recolour them, or add your own.
MLB starting pitchers in the Hall of Fame, greatest first.
Every pick and every finished ranking here counts toward the top hall of Fame MLB starting pitchers for November 2026.
How to use it
- Drag each tile into a tier, or tap a tile and then a row.
- Reorder tiles within a row to rank inside the tier.
- Use the sort menu and the Players bar to change who you start with.
- Missing someone? Use + Add or the search box under the board to bring in any player, team or legend.
- Download image saves a picture with your name or logo on it; Copy link shares this exact board. Your progress is kept in this browser.