Hall of Fame MLB starting pitchers bracket

MLB starting pitchers in the Hall of Fame, greatest first. Make a hall of Fame MLB starting pitchers bracket at the size you want and choose the champion.

PlaySize

Pick a champion to submit your bracket.

Save to my profile keeps it to come back to and keep ranking. Submit your ranking adds it to this month's top list.

Tap the winner of each match, or drag them into the next round · 15 matches left

Round of 16

1Sandy Koufax

16Whitey Ford

8Cy Young

9Dennis Eckersley

4Lefty Grove

13Pedro Martinez

5Nolan Ryan

12Walter Johnson

2Babe Ruth

15Tom Glavine

7Randy Johnson

10Roy Halladay

3Warren Spahn

14Greg Maddux

6Rollie Fingers

11Christy Mathewson

Quarterfinals

Semifinals

Final

Seeds

Drag to reorder (or tap one, then tap where it goes). The top 16 are in. Changing seeds keeps the picks that still fit.

1

Sandy Koufax1955–1966

2

Babe Ruth1914–1935

3

Warren Spahn1942–1965

4

Lefty Grove1925–1941

5

Nolan Ryan1966–1993

6

Rollie Fingers

7

Randy Johnson1988–2009

8

Cy Young1890–1911

9

Dennis Eckersley1975–1998

10

Roy Halladay1998–2013

11

Christy Mathewson1900–1916

12

Walter Johnson1907–1927

13

Pedro Martinez1992–2009

14

Greg Maddux1986–2008

15

Tom Glavine1987–2008

16

Whitey Ford1950–1967

–

Jim Palmer1965–1984

–

John Smoltz1988–2009

–

Tom Seaver1967–1986

–

Steve Carlton1965–1988

–

Gaylord Perry1962–1983

–

CC Sabathia2001–2019

–

Ferguson Jenkins1965–1983

–

Dizzy Dean1930–1947

–

Hal Newhouser1939–1955

–

Carl Hubbell1928–1943

–

Catfish Hunter1965–1979

–

Bruce Sutter1976–1988

–

Early Wynn1939–1963

–

Jim Bunning1955–1971

–

Phil Niekro1964–1987

–

Satchel Paige1948–1965

–

Jack Morris1977–1994

–

Mike Mussina1991–2008

–

Don Drysdale

–

Lefty Gomez1930–1943

–

Jim Kaat1959–1983

–

Bert Blyleven1970–1992

–

Ted Lyons1923–1946

–

Bob Feller1936–1956

–

Trevor Hoffman1993–2010

–

Billy Wagner1995–2010

–

Don Sutton1966–1988

–

Robin Roberts1948–1966

–

Juan Marichal1960–1975

–

Red Ruffing

–

Bob Lemon1941–1958

–

Grover Cleveland Alexander1911–1930

–

Stan Coveleski1912–1928

–

Burleigh Grimes1932–1933

–

Chief Bender

–

Tim Keefe1880–1893

–

Herb Pennock

–

Waite Hoyt

–

Dazzy Vance1915–1935

–

Red Faber1914–1933

–

Mickey Welch1880–1892

–

Eppa Rixey1912–1933

–

Eddie Plank1901–1917

–

Jack Chesbro1899–1909

–

Jesse Haines1918–

–

Tommy Lasorda1954–1956

–

Clark Calvin Griffith

–

Amos Rusie1889–1901

–

Albert Spalding1876–1878

–

Ed Walsh

–

Charles Comiskey1892–1894

–

John Clarkson

–

Cristiano Ronaldo

–

Kid Nichols

–

Joe McCarthy

–

Rube Marquard

–

Joe McGinnity

–

Hank O'Day

Top hall of Fame MLB starting pitchers — November 2026

See the full top list →

No top list yet this month — your picks and finished rankings start it.

How a bracket works

A bracket is a knockout: each matchup sends one winner to the next round until a single champion is left.

Change a pick in an early round and the later rounds update to follow it.

MLB starting pitchers in the Hall of Fame, greatest first.

Every pick and every finished ranking here counts toward the top hall of Fame MLB starting pitchers for November 2026.

How to make yours

Choose a size, from 4 to 64.
Tap the winner of each matchup, or drag them into the next round.
Change a pick at any time; later rounds update.
To add someone who isn't there, search for them in the box under the board or use + Add.
Your board stays in this browser while you work. Save it to your profile, download the picture, or share a link.

Other MLB positions

Closers Catchers First basemen Second basemen Third basemen Shortstops Outfielders Designated hitters