All-time New York Yankees, head to head
344 players who played for the Yankees, greatest for the team first; search for anyone else. Rank all-time New York Yankees head to head.
Which is better? Tap one, or drag it onto “vs” · 0 answered, about 128 to go
Joe DiMaggioCF · NYY
vsDrop the winner
Mickey MantleCF · NYY
- 1
Mickey Mantle
CF · NYY
Top all-time New York Yankees — November 2026
See the full top list →No top list yet this month — your picks and finished rankings start it.
About this head to head
Head to head ranks by comparison: you only ever choose between two. Every pick narrows it down until your full ranking falls out.
344 players who played for the Yankees, greatest for the team first; search for anyone else.
Every pick and every finished ranking here counts toward the top all-time New York Yankees for November 2026.
How to use it
- Pick the better player of each pair.
- Keep going — the count shows how many picks are left.
- Your ranking builds below as you go.
- Use the Players bar to rank a different group: stars, a position, Hall of Famers.
- Download image saves a picture with your name or logo on it; Copy link shares this exact board. Your progress is kept in this browser.