All-time New York Yankees Mount Rushmore

344 players who played for the Yankees, greatest for the team first; search for anyone else. Choose the four all-time New York Yankees who belong on your Mount Rushmore.

Fill all 4 to submit (4 left).

Save to my profile keeps it to come back to and keep ranking. Submit your ranking adds it to this month's top list.

1

2

3

4

80 to choose from · drag one onto a spot, or tap it then the spot

Mickey Mantle

CF · NYY

Joe DiMaggio

CF · NYY

Yogi Berra

C · NYY

Lou Gehrig

1B · NYY

Babe Ruth

P/OF · NYY

Roger Clemens

P · NYY

Reggie Jackson

RF · NYY

Derek Jeter

SS · NYY

Mariano Rivera

RP · NYY

Whitey Ford

SP · NYY

Phil Rizzuto

SS · NYY

CC Sabathia

P · NYY

Dave Winfield

DH/OF · NYY

Giancarlo Stanton

LF · NYY

Alex Rodriguez

SS/3B · NYY

Aaron Judge

OF · NYY

Mike Mussina

SP · NYY

Catfish Hunter

SP · NYY

Lefty Gomez

P · NYY

Wade Boggs

3B · NYY

Goose Gossage

RP · NYY

Roger Maris

RF · NYY

Ichiro Suzuki

OF · NYY

Don Mattingly

1B · NYY

Johnny Mize

1B · NYY

Willie Keeler

RF · NYY

Gerrit Cole

SP · NYY

Burleigh Grimes

P · NYY

Jack Chesbro

P · NYY

Jason Giambi

1B · NYY

David Cone

SP · NYY

Thurman Munson

C · NYY

Ron Guidry

SP · NYY

Rickey Henderson

LF · NYY

Mark Teixeira

1B · NYY

Joe Gordon

2B · NYY

Masahiro Tanaka

SP · NYY

DJ LeMahieu

2B · NYY

Hideki Matsui

DH/OF · NYY

Randy Johnson

P · NYY

Alfonso Soriano

LF · NYY

Robinson Canó

2B · NYY

Bobby Richardson

2B · NYY

Sparky Lyle

P · NYY

Jacoby Ellsbury

CF · NYY

Willie Randolph

2B · NYY

Carlos Beltrán

DH/CF · NYY

Bernie Williams

CF · NYY

Graig Nettles

3B · NYY

Tim Raines

LF · NYY

Brett Gardner

OF · NYY

Jorge Posada

DF · NYY

Tommy John

P · NYY

Aroldis Chapman

P · NYY

Tony Lazzeri

2B · NYY

Ralph Terry

P · NYY

Bill Dickey

C · NYY

Bobby Shantz

P · NYY

Darryl Strawberry

RF · NYY

Gary Sánchez

C · NYY

David Robertson

P · NYY

Red Ruffing

P · NYY

Leo Durocher

SS · NYY

Paul Waner

RF · NYY

Billy Martin

SS · NYY

Anthony Rizzo

1B · NYY

Don Baylor

DH · NYY

Bucky Dent

SS · NYY

Enos Slaughter

RF · NYY

Andy Pettitte

SP · NYY

Andruw Jones

DH/CF · NYY

Chris Chambliss

1B · NYY

Don Larsen

P · NYY

Herb Pennock

P · NYY

Jerry Coleman

2B · NYY

Dellin Betances

P · NYY

Phil Niekro

SP/P · NYY

Waite Hoyt

P · NYY

Home Run Baker

3B · NYY

Earle Combs

CF · NYY

Top all-time New York Yankees — November 2026

See the full top list →

No top list yet this month — your picks and finished rankings start it.

What a Mount Rushmore is for

The four faces are carved into the mountain in order, first to fourth, each with a name plate below.

Make one for a single era or team, and another for all time, to see how your four players change.

344 players who played for the Yankees, greatest for the team first; search for anyone else.

Every pick and every finished ranking here counts toward the top all-time New York Yankees for November 2026.

Step by step

Fill the four spots from first to fourth.
Use the ✕ on a face to clear it and choose again.
The search box under the board finds anyone else you want to add.
Download image saves a picture of your board with your name or logo on it, and Copy link shares this exact board.