All-time St. Louis Cardinals tier list

344 players who played for the Cardinals, greatest for the team first; search for anyone else. Rank all-time St. Louis Cardinals from S to F.

Place at least 10 to submit your ranking (0 so far).

Save to my profile keeps it to come back to and keep ranking. Submit your ranking adds it to this month's top list.

S

A

B

C

D

E

F

Drag a tile into a tier, or tap it then tap a tier

Rogers Hornsby

2B · STL

Joe Torre

C · STL

Steve Carlton

P · STL

Dizzy Dean

P · STL

Albert Pujols

P/1B · STL

Scott Rolen

3B · STL

Johnny Mize

1B · STL

Paul Goldschmidt

1B · STL

Red Schoendienst

2B · STL

Jim Bottomley

1B · STL

Miller Huggins

2B · STL

Matt Holliday

LF · STL

Keith Hernandez

1B · STL

Terry Pendleton

3B · STL

Ken Boyer

3B · STL

Orlando Cepeda

1B · STL

Chris Carpenter

SP · STL

Edgar Rentería

SS · STL

Jim Kaat

P · STL

Lee Smith

RP · STL

Mort Cooper

P · STL

Cy Young

P · STL

Jim Edmonds

CF · STL

Grover Cleveland Alexander

P · STL

Dennis Eckersley

P · STL

Roger Connor

1B · STL

Michael Wacha

SP · STL

John Denny

P · STL

Nolan Arenado

3B · STL

Matt Carpenter

2B · STL

Tommy McCarthy

RF · STL

Plácido Polanco

3B · STL

David Freese

3B · STL

Lance Lynn

P · STL

Jason Isringhausen

P · STL

Garry Templeton

SS · STL

J. D. Drew

CF · STL

Carlos Beltrán

DH/CF · STL

Miles Mikolas

RP · STL

Bobby Shantz

P · STL

Tim McCarver

C · STL

Matt Morris

P · STL

Joaquín Andújar

SP · STL

Dick Groat

PG · STL

Ryan Franklin

P · STL

Wally Moon

OF · STL

Curt Simmons

P · STL

José Cruz

LF · STL

Tommy Edman

STL

Roger Maris

RF · STL

Harvey Haddix

P · STL

Andy Van Slyke

CF · STL

Walker Cooper

C · STL

Allen Craig

RF · STL

John Smoltz

P/SP · STL

Dick Allen

1B/3B · STL

Dazzy Vance

P · STL

Dexter Fowler

CF · STL

Harrison Bader

OF · STL

Bob Forsch

P · STL

Jhonny Peralta

SS · STL

Reggie Smith

OF · STL

Ryan Ludwick

OF · STL

Andy Benes

P · STL

Bob Tewksbury

P · STL

Brett Cecil

SP · STL

David Eckstein

SS · STL

Willson Contreras

C/1B · STL

Ken Hill

SP · STL

Don Blasingame

2B · STL

Mark Mulder

P · STL

Troy Glaus

3B · STL

Minnie Miñoso

LF · STL

Jason Marquis

P · STL

Fernando Valenzuela

SP · STL

Marcell Ozuna

CF · STL

Terry Kennedy

C · STL

Andrew Miller

P · STL

Alvin Dark

C · STL

Ron Gant

LF · STL

Top all-time St. Louis Cardinals — November 2026

See the full top list →

No top list yet this month — your picks and finished rankings start it.

About this tier list

A tier list sorts everyone into rows from S (the best) to F. Rename the rows, recolour them, or add your own.

344 players who played for the Cardinals, greatest for the team first; search for anyone else.

Every pick and every finished ranking here counts toward the top all-time St. Louis Cardinals for November 2026.

How to use it

Drag each tile into a tier, or tap a tile and then a row.
Reorder tiles within a row to rank inside the tier.
Use the sort menu and the Players bar to change who you start with.
Missing someone? Use + Add or the search box under the board to bring in any player, team or legend.
Download image saves a picture with your name or logo on it; Copy link shares this exact board. Your progress is kept in this browser.