All-time St. Louis Cardinals Mount Rushmore
344 players who played for the Cardinals, greatest for the team first; search for anyone else. Carve your all-time St. Louis Cardinals Mount Rushmore.
Fill all 4 to submit (4 left).
Save to my profile keeps it to come back to and keep ranking. Submit your ranking adds it to this month's top list.
1
2
3
4
80 to choose from · drag one onto a spot, or tap it then the spot
_MET_DPB881959.jpg/330px-Rogers_Hornsby%2C_2_B_-_St._Louis_N.%2C_from_Baseball_strip_cards_(W575-2)_MET_DPB881959.jpg)
Rogers Hornsby2B · STL
Joe TorreC · STL
Steve CarltonP · STL
Dizzy DeanP · STL
Albert PujolsP/1B · STL
Scott Rolen3B · STL
Johnny Mize1B · STL
Paul Goldschmidt1B · STL
.jpg/330px-Red_Schoendienst_Model_G119_MacGregor_Baseball_Glove_of_Nancy_Fronckewicz_-_DPLA_-_7b72e6a28b36b1c6890988f9444357ca_(page_3).jpg)
Red Schoendienst2B · STL
Jim Bottomley1B · STL
_(LOC)_2.jpg/330px-Miller_Huggins%2C_St._Louis_NL_(baseball)_(LOC)_2.jpg)
Miller Huggins2B · STL
Matt HollidayLF · STL
Keith Hernandez1B · STL
Terry Pendleton3B · STL
Ken Boyer3B · STL
Orlando Cepeda1B · STL
Chris CarpenterSP · STL
Edgar RenteríaSS · STL
Jim KaatP · STL
Lee SmithRP · STL
Mort CooperP · STL
Cy YoungP · STL
Jim EdmondsCF · STL
Grover Cleveland AlexanderP · STL
Dennis EckersleyP · STL
Roger Connor1B · STL
Michael WachaSP · STL
John DennyP · STL
Nolan Arenado3B · STL
Matt Carpenter2B · STL
Tommy McCarthyRF · STL
Plácido Polanco3B · STL
David Freese3B · STL
Lance LynnP · STL
Jason IsringhausenP · STL
Garry TempletonSS · STL
J. D. DrewCF · STL
Carlos BeltránDH/CF · STL
Miles MikolasRP · STL
.jpg/330px-Bobby_Shantz_1953_(2).jpg)
Bobby ShantzP · STL
Tim McCarverC · STL
Matt MorrisP · STL
Joaquín AndújarSP · STL
Dick GroatPG · STL
Ryan FranklinP · STL
Wally MoonOF · STL
Curt SimmonsP · STL
José CruzLF · STL
Tommy EdmanSTL
Roger MarisRF · STL
Harvey HaddixP · STL
Andy Van SlykeCF · STL
Walker CooperC · STL
Allen CraigRF · STL
John SmoltzP/SP · STL
Dick Allen1B/3B · STL
.jpg/330px-Former_professional_baseball_player_Dazzy_Vance_duck_hunting_in_Crystal_River_(15245079568).jpg)
Dazzy VanceP · STL
Dexter FowlerCF · STL
Harrison BaderOF · STL
Bob ForschP · STL
Jhonny PeraltaSS · STL
.jpg/330px-Mets_vs_Dodgers_-_1978_(cropped).jpg)
Reggie SmithOF · STL
Ryan LudwickOF · STL
.jpg/330px-Andy_Benes_(crop).jpg)
Andy BenesP · STL
Bob TewksburyP · STL
Brett CecilSP · STL
David EcksteinSS · STL
Willson ContrerasC/1B · STL
Ken HillSP · STL
Don Blasingame2B · STL
Mark MulderP · STL
Troy Glaus3B · STL
Minnie MiñosoLF · STL
Jason MarquisP · STL
Fernando ValenzuelaSP · STL
Marcell OzunaCF · STL
Terry KennedyC · STL
Andrew MillerP · STL
Alvin DarkC · STL
Ron GantLF · STL
Top all-time St. Louis Cardinals — November 2026
See the full top list →No top list yet this month — your picks and finished rankings start it.
About this Mount Rushmore
Four spots, for the four who define it. Who makes the mountain?
344 players who played for the Cardinals, greatest for the team first; search for anyone else.
Every pick and every finished ranking here counts toward the top all-time St. Louis Cardinals for November 2026.
How to use it
- Click a spot to choose who goes there.
- Drag one face onto another to swap them.
- Download image saves a picture with your name or logo on it; Copy link shares this exact board. Your progress is kept in this browser.