All-time NFL punters face-off
The greatest punters in NFL history, by their honors. Pit all-time NFL punters against each other row by row, one on one or in twos and threes, and keep score.
Drag pictures onto both sides of a row to make a matchup
0–00 even
58 not in a matchup · drag one onto either side of a row (up to 4 a side)
Ray GuyP · LV
Shane LechlerP · LV
.JPG/330px-John_Lynch_(American_football).JPG)
John LynchS/P · TB
SLSean Landeta
P · NYG
John HekkerP · LAR
Brian MoormanP · BUF
JWJerrel Wilson
P · KC
DBDarren Bennett
P · LAC
.png/330px-Pat_McAfee_on_The_Pat_McAfee_Show_8.31.2022_(cropped).png)
Pat McAfeeFW/P · IND
RRReggie Roby
P · MIA
Michael DicksonP · SEA
.JPG/330px-Andy_Lee_(American_football).JPG)
Andy LeeP · SF
Jeff FeaglesP · NYG
Brett KernP · TEN
Thomas MorsteadP · NO
Ron WidbyP · DAL
Jake BaileyP · NE
Mitch BergerP · PIT
Chris HansonP · JAX
Logan CookeP · JAX
A. J. Cole IIIP · LV
JJJohn James
P · ATL
TTTom Tupa
P · ARI
Chris GardockiP · PIT
Jeff GossettP · CLE
Mat McBriarP · DAL
.jpg/330px-Josh_Bidwell_(cropped).jpg)
Josh BidwellP · TB
Craig HentrichP · GB
Bryan AngerP · DAL
RTRick Tuten
P · SEA
MHMike Horan
P · DEN
JAJim Arnold
P · DET
Matt TurkP · LAR
DHDale Hatcher
P · LAR
Tommy TownsendP · KC
BBBryan Barker
P · JAX
.png/330px-Chiefs_Punter_Dustin_Colquitt_Super_Bowl_54_Interview_(cropped).png)
Dustin ColquittP · KC
TSTodd Sauerbrun
P · CAR
PMPat McInally
P · CIN
BGBob Grupp
P · KC
SPScott Player
P · NYJ
Ryan AllenP · NE
Britton ColquittP · DEN
Donnie JonesP · PHI
Jon RyanP · SEA
Chris KluweP · MIN
.jpg/330px-Kevin_Huber_2021_(cropped).jpg)
Kevin HuberP · CIN
KRKyle Richardson
P · BAL
Adam PodleshP · CHI
Tim MasthayP · GB
Hunter SmithP · IND
CCCraig Colquitt
P · PIT
Josh MillerP · TEN
TRTom Rouen
P · DEN
Jason BakerP · CAR
.jpg/330px-Brad_Maynard_(Chicago_Bears_training_camp%2C_2009).jpg)
Brad MaynardP · CHI
Robert MaloneP · JAX
Sam KochP · BAL
Top all-time NFL punters — November 2026
See the full top list →No top list yet this month — your picks and finished rankings start it.
What a face-off is for
Rows can be one against one, two against two, three against three, or uneven, so a whole team can face a single star.
Name the two sides, like two generations, two eras or two rosters, and fill each row with their closest counterparts.
The greatest punters in NFL history, by their honors.
Every pick and every finished ranking here counts toward the top all-time NFL punters for November 2026.
Step by step
- Deal a random set of matchups, or clear the board and drag pictures onto either side of each row.
- Tap the better side of each row, or the = in the middle when they're even.
- Download the picture or save it so others can call the same matchups.
- The search box under the board finds anyone else you want to add.
- Download image saves a picture of your board with your name or logo on it, and Copy link shares this exact board.