All-time Indianapolis Colts bracket

221 players who played for the Colts, greatest for the team first; search for anyone else. Fill out a all-time Indianapolis Colts bracket.

PlaySize

Pick a champion to submit your bracket.

Save to my profile keeps it to come back to and keep ranking. Submit your ranking adds it to this month's top list.

Tap the winner of each match · 15 matches left

Round of 16

Quarterfinals

Semifinals

Final

Seeds

Drag to reorder (or tap one, then tap where it goes). The top 16 are in. Changing seeds keeps the picks that still fit.

1

Peyton Manning1998–2015

2

Marvin Harrison1996–2008

3

Adam Vinatieri1996–2019

4

Eric Dickerson1983–1993

5

Marshall Faulk1994–2006

6

Dwight Freeney2002–2017

7

Edgerrin James1999–2009

8

Ted Hendricks

9

Johnny Unitas

10

John Mackey

11

Y. A. Tittle

12

Joe Perry

13

Andrew Luck2012–2018

14

Bob Sanders2004–2011

15

Pat McAfee2009–2016

16

Reggie Wayne2001–2014

–

Jeff Saturday2000–2012

–

Antoine Bethea2006–2019

–

Joseph Addai2006–2011

–

T. Y. Hilton2012–2022

–

Ryan Kelly2016–

–

Quenton Nelson2018–2026

–

Shaquille Leonard2018–2023

–

BJ

Bert Jones

–

Robert Mathis2003–2016

–

Jack Doyle2013–2021

–

MC

Mike Curtis1977–1978

–

Kenny Moore2017–2026

–

Don Shula1953–1995

–

Frank Gore2005–2020

–

Bubba Smith

–

Earl Morrall

–

Zaire Franklin2018–2026

–

Mike Vanderjagt1998–2006

–

CB

Cornelius Bennett

–

Jim Harbaugh

–

Tim Jennings2006–2009

–

Richard Dent1983–1997

–

Andre Johnson2003–2016

–

Cato June2003–2009

–

CH

Chris Hinton

–

Matt Hasselbeck

–

Matt Ryan2008–2022

–

Marcus Washington2000–2008

–

Philip Rivers2004–2025

–

Chris Chandler

–

Matt Bryant

–

Joe Klecko1977–1988

–

Dwight Hicks

–

Mitch Berger

–

Martin Gramatica

–

Sauce Gardner2022–2026

–

Ken Hamlin

–

Walt Harris

–

JW

Joe Washington

–

Jerome Felton

–

SR

Simeon Rice

–

Chris Gardocki

–

GL

Greg Landry

–

Bill Curry

–

DB

Dean Biasucci

–

SM

Stanley Morgan

–

Toni Linhart

–

Roy Jefferson

–

GK

George Kunz

–

Tarik Glenn

–

RC

Raymond Chester

–

Anthony Gonzalez2007–2012

–

Alex Agase

–

CH

Craig Heyward

–

DB

Duane Bickett

–

Bertrand Berry

–

RS

Ron Solt

–

EJ

Ezra Johnson

–

KD

Ken Dilger

–

DP

Dave Pear

–

RC

Roger Carr

–

Rick Volk

–

NB

Norm Bulaich

–

JD

John Dutton

Top all-time Indianapolis Colts — November 2026

See the full top list →

No top list yet this month — your picks and finished rankings start it.

About this bracket

A knockout bracket: pick the winner of every matchup, round by round, until one is left.

221 players who played for the Colts, greatest for the team first; search for anyone else.

Every pick and every finished ranking here counts toward the top all-time Indianapolis Colts for November 2026.

How to use it

Choose a size, from 4 to 64.
Click the winner of each matchup to move them on.
Change a pick at any time; later rounds update.
Download image saves a picture with your name or logo on it; Copy link shares this exact board. Your progress is kept in this browser.