All-time Indianapolis Colts pyramid
221 players who played for the Colts, greatest for the team first; search for anyone else. Choose the one that belongs at the top of your all-time Indianapolis Colts pyramid, then fill the wider levels below.
Fill every level to submit your ranking (31 spots left).
Save to my profile keeps it to come back to and keep ranking. Submit your ranking adds it to this month's top list.
S
A
B
C
D
E
80 to place · each level holds only what fits
Peyton ManningQB · IND
Marvin HarrisonWR · IND
Adam VinatieriK · IND
.jpg/330px-Tulsa_vs._Southern_Methodist_football_2021_19_(Eric_Dickerson).jpg)
Eric DickersonRB · IND
Marshall FaulkRB · IND
Dwight FreeneyDE · IND
Edgerrin JamesRB · IND
Ted HendricksLB · IND
Johnny UnitasQB · IND
John MackeyRB/TE · IND
Y. A. TittleQB · IND
Joe PerryIND
Andrew LuckQB · IND
Bob SandersS · IND
.png/330px-Pat_McAfee_on_The_Pat_McAfee_Show_8.31.2022_(cropped).png)
Pat McAfeeFW/P · IND
Reggie WayneWR · IND
Jeff SaturdayC · IND
Antoine BetheaS · IND
Joseph AddaiRB · IND
T. Y. HiltonWR · IND
_03.jpg/330px-Ryan_Kelly_at_Syracuse_Orange_football_quad_walk_(2024)_03.jpg)
Ryan KellyC · IND
Quenton NelsonIND
Shaquille LeonardLB · IND
BJBert Jones
QB · IND
Robert MathisLB · IND
Jack DoyleTE · IND
MCMike Curtis
LB · IND
Kenny MooreCB · IND
Don ShulaIND
Frank GoreRB · IND
Bubba SmithDE · IND
Earl MorrallQB · IND
Zaire FranklinLB · IND
Mike VanderjagtK · IND
CBCornelius Bennett
LB · IND
Jim HarbaughQB · IND
.JPG/330px-Tim_Jennings_2013_Pro_Bowl_(cropped).JPG)
Tim JenningsCB · IND
_(cropped).jpg/330px-Richard_Dent_(250130-M-LM126-1263)_(cropped).jpg)
Richard DentDE · IND
Andre JohnsonWR · IND
Cato JuneLB · IND
CHChris Hinton
OT · IND
Matt HasselbeckQB · IND
Matt RyanQB · IND
Marcus WashingtonLB · IND
Philip RiversQB · IND
Chris ChandlerQB · IND
Matt BryantK · IND
Joe KleckoIND
Dwight HicksS · IND
Mitch BergerP · IND
Martin GramaticaK · IND
Sauce GardnerIND
Ken HamlinS · IND
Walt HarrisCB · IND
JWJoe Washington
RB · IND
.JPG/330px-Jerome_Felton_2013_Pro_Bowl_(cropped).JPG)
Jerome FeltonIND
SRSimeon Rice
DE · IND
Chris GardockiP · IND
GLGreg Landry
QB · IND
Bill CurryC · IND
DBDean Biasucci
K · IND
SMStanley Morgan
WR · IND
Toni LinhartDF · IND
Roy JeffersonWR · IND
GKGeorge Kunz
OT · IND
_(cropped).jpg/330px-Tarik_Glenn_(52480549280)_(cropped).jpg)
Tarik GlennOT · IND
RCRaymond Chester
TE · IND
Anthony GonzalezWR · IND
Alex AgaseIND
CHCraig Heyward
RB · IND
DBDuane Bickett
LB · IND
Bertrand BerryDE · IND
RSRon Solt
IND
EJEzra Johnson
DE · IND
KDKen Dilger
TE · IND
DPDave Pear
DT · IND
RCRoger Carr
WR · IND
.jpg/330px-1986_Jeno's_Pizza_-_31_-_Rick_Volk_and_Leroy_Kelly_(Rick_Volk_crop).jpg)
Rick VolkS · IND
NBNorm Bulaich
RB · IND
JDJohn Dutton
DE · IND
Top all-time Indianapolis Colts — November 2026
See the full top list →No top list yet this month — your picks and finished rankings start it.
About this pyramid
The narrow top makes a pyramid good for settling the debate over number one, while the wide base still has room for the rest.
Try filling the bottom first and working up, so the last choices you make are the toughest ones.
221 players who played for the Colts, greatest for the team first; search for anyone else.
Every pick and every finished ranking here counts toward the top all-time Indianapolis Colts for November 2026.
How to use it
- Start with your number one and place it at the top.
- Fill each level below; a full level won't take another until you move one out.
- Move a tile between levels by dragging it.
- If someone is missing, use + Add or the search box under the board to bring them in.
- When you're done, download the picture or copy a link that opens your board as you left it.