All-time MLB closers face-off

The greatest closers in MLB history, by their honors. Line up all-time MLB closers two sides at a time and call every matchup: one side's better, or they're even.

Drag pictures onto both sides of a row to make a matchup
0–00 even
100 not in a matchup · drag one onto either side of a row (up to 4 a side)
Mariano Rivera
RP · NYY
Hoyt Wilhelm
RP · ATL
Lee Smith
RP · CHC
Trevor Hoffman
P/RP · SD
Goose Gossage
RP · NYY
Billy Wagner
P/RP · HOU
Willie Hernández
RP · CHC
Josh Hader
RP · MIL
Jim Konstanty
RP · PHI
Mike Marshall
RP · WSH
Mark Davis
RP · SD
Fernando Rodney
RP · DET
Francisco Rodríguez
P/RP · LAA
José Valverde
RP · ARI
Wade Davis
RP · KC
Greg Holland
RP · KC
Jeff Reardon
RP · WSH
John Wetteland
RP · WSH
Seth Lugo
RP · NYM
Brian Wilson
RP · SF
Tom Gordon
RP · KC
Joakim Soria
RP · KC
Neftalí Feliz
RP · TEX
Zack Britton
RP · BAL
Brian Fuentes
RP · COL
Randy Myers
RP · NYM
UUUgueth Urbina
RP · WSH
Andrew Bailey
RP · ATH
Jim Johnson
RP · BAL
Sean Doolittle
RP · ATH
Pat Neshek
RP · MIN
Rafael Soriano
RP · SEA
Darren O'Day
RP · BAL
Mark Melancon
RP · PIT
Joe Nathan
P/RP · MIN
Kirby Yates
RP · SD
Tyler Clippard
RP · WSH
Grant Balfour
RP · TB
Heath Bell
RP · SD
Brad Brach
RP · BAL
Miles Mikolas
RP · STL
Kelvin Herrera
RP · KC
Ryan Cook
RP · ATH
Will Harris
RP · HOU
Brad Boxberger
RP · TB
Mike Stanton
RP · NYY
Duane Ward
RP · TOR
Alfredo Simón
RP · BAL
Jonathan Broxton
RP · LAD
Sergio Romo
RP · SF
Corey Knebel
RP · MIL
Carlos Mármol
RP · CHC
Keith Foulke
RP · CHW
Arthur Rhodes
RP · BAL
J. J. Putz
RP · SEA
Norm Charlton
RP · CIN
Jason Grilli
RP · PIT
SWScott Williamson
RP · CIN
José Mesa
RP · CLE
Matt Thornton
RP · CHW
Rob Dibble
RP · CIN
Brad Lidge
RP · HOU
Matt Capps
RP · PIT
Steve Delabar
RP · TOR
Ryan Pressly
RP · HOU
Kazuhiro Sasaki
RP · SEA
Roberto Hernández
RP · CHW
George Sherrill
RP · SEA
Jesse Orosco
RP · NYM
Todd Jones
RP · DET
Chris Perez
RP · CLE
John Franco
RP · NYM
Chad Cordero
RP · WSH
THTom Henke
RP · TOR
Daniel Bard
RP · BOS
JSJeff Shaw
RP · LAD
Eddie Guardado
RP · MIN
Mitch Williams
RP · PHI
Brandon Kintzler
RP · MIL
Gregg Olson
RP · BAL
Aaron Crow
RP · KC
Jon Rauch
RP · WSH
Brian Bruney
RP · NYY
Boone Logan
RP · NYY
Manny Delcarmen
RP · BOS
Jake McGee
RP · TB
Kevin Jepsen
RP · LAA
J. P. Howell
RP · TB
BKBilly Koch
RP · TOR
Luis Vizcaíno
RP · ATH
John Axford
RP · MIL
Javier López
RP · SF
Jason Motte
RP · STL
Chris Martin
RP · TEX
Ronald Belisario
RP · LAD
Cody Allen
RP · CLE
Cam Bedrosian
RP · LAA
Scott McGough
RP · ARI
Guillermo Moscoso
RP · TEX
Brad Ziegler
RP · ARI

Top all-time MLB closers — November 2026

See the full top list →

No top list yet this month — your picks and finished rankings start it.

How a face-off works

A face-off sets two sides against each other across a line. Each row is a matchup, and you call it for the left, the right, or even.

Play matchups goes through the rows one at a time, as big as your screen allows.

The greatest closers in MLB history, by their honors.

Every pick and every finished ranking here counts toward the top all-time MLB closers for November 2026.

How to make yours

  1. Pick how many rows and what mix of matchups to deal.
  2. Call each row: left, right or even.
  3. Share the score, or save it for others to try.
  4. To add someone who isn't there, search for them in the box under the board or use + Add.
  5. Your board stays in this browser while you work. Save it to your profile, download the picture, or share a link.

More MLB