All-time MLB second basemen face-off
The greatest second basemen in MLB history, by their honors. Deal a random set of all-time MLB second basemen matchups, or build your own, then pick a side in each.
Drag pictures onto both sides of a row to make a matchup
0–00 even
100 not in a matchup · drag one onto either side of a row (up to 4 a side)
Jackie Robinson2B · LAD
_MET_DPB881959.jpg/330px-Rogers_Hornsby%2C_2_B_-_St._Louis_N.%2C_from_Baseball_strip_cards_(W575-2)_MET_DPB881959.jpg)
Rogers Hornsby2B · STL
Joe Morgan2B · HOU
Ryne Sandberg2B · CHC
Jeff Kent2B · SF
Nellie Fox2B · CHW
.jpg/330px-Joe_Gordon_1942_(2).jpg)
Joe Gordon2B · NYY
Charlie Gehringer2B · DET
José Altuve2B · HOU
Bobby Doerr2B · BOS
Tony Lazzeri2B · NYY
Dustin Pedroia2B · BOS
)_LOC_2162649157.jpg/330px-(Eddie_Collins%2C_Philadelphia%2C_AL_(baseball))_LOC_2162649157.jpg)
Eddie Collins2B · ATH
.jpg/330px-Red_Schoendienst_Model_G119_MacGregor_Baseball_Glove_of_Nancy_Fronckewicz_-_DPLA_-_7b72e6a28b36b1c6890988f9444357ca_(page_3).jpg)
Red Schoendienst2B · STL
Billy Herman2B · CHC
Tony La Russa2B · ATH
Nap Lajoie2B · ATH
_LCCN2014688314.jpg/330px-Johnny_Evers%2C_Chicago%2C_NL_(baseball)_LCCN2014688314.jpg)
Johnny Evers2B · CHC
_(LOC)_2.jpg/330px-Miller_Huggins%2C_St._Louis_NL_(baseball)_(LOC)_2.jpg)
Miller Huggins2B · STL
Bid McPhee2B · CIN
Bucky Harris2B · MIN
Sparky Anderson2B · DET
DJ LeMahieu2B · NYY
Ben ZobristOF/2B · TB
Robinson Canó2B · NYY
Bobby Richardson2B · NYY
Anthony Rendon3B/2B · WSH
Chase Utley2B · PHI
Davey Johnson2B · BAL
Manny Trillo2B · CHC
Bret Boone2B · SEA
Willie Randolph2B · NYY
Ian Kinsler2B · TEX
Brandon Phillips2B · CIN
Daniel Murphy2B · NYM
Chuck Knoblauch2B · NYY
Steve Sax2B · LAD
Aaron Hill2B · TOR
Matt Carpenter2B · STL
Starlin Castro2B · CHC
Mark Loretta2B · MIL
Ozhaino Albies2B · ATL
Jean SeguraSS/2B · MIL
Yuli Gurriel1B/2B · HOU
Lou Whitaker2B · DET
Howard Kendrick2B · LAA
Glenn Beckert2B · CHC
Luis Castillo2B · MIA
Joe Panik2B · SF
Bobby Grich2B · LAA
Orlando Hudson2B · TOR
Harold Reynolds2B · BAL
Dan Uggla2B · MIA
Jerry Coleman2B · NYY
Davey Lopes2B · LAD
Mark Grudzielanek2B · LAD
Jonathan Schoop2B · BAL
Omar Infante2B · DET
Whit Merrifield2B · KC
Josh Harrison2B · PIT
Frank Bolling2B · DET
Dámaso García2B · TOR
Juan Samuel2B · PHI
Ian Happ2B · CHC
Gleyber TorresSS/2B · NYY
Bo BichetteSS/2B · TOR
Brian Roberts2B · BAL
Jason Kipnis2B/CF · CLE
José López2B · SEA
Freddy Sanchez2B · PIT
Darwin Barney2B · CHC
Neil Walker2B · PIT
_-_Damion_Easley.jpg/330px-Damion_Easley_(cropped)_-_Damion_Easley.jpg)
Damion Easley2B · DET
_(cropped).jpg/330px-Carlos_Baerga_(18855184719)_(cropped).jpg)
Carlos Baerga2B · CLE
Charlie Neal2B · CIN
José Vidro2B · WSH
_(cropped).jpg/330px-Tony_Womack_(112647180)_(cropped).jpg)
Tony Womack2B · ARI
Tommy La Stella2B/3B · CHC
.jpg/330px-Tony_Taylor_(cropped).jpg)
Tony Taylor2B · PHI
Mariano Duncan2B · LAD
Kim Ha-seongSS/2B · SD
Marco Scutaro2B · SF
Scooter Gennett2B · MIL
Brandon Lowe2B · TB
Edgardo Alfonzo2B · NYM
FVFernando Viña
2B · MIL
Eric Young2B · COL
Addison Russell2B · CHC
Glenn Hubbard2B · ATL
Ray Durham2B · CHW
_(cropped).jpg/330px-Sandy_Alomar_Sr_(3639906733)_(cropped).jpg)
Sandy Alomar, Sr.2B · ATL
Joey Cora2B · CHW
Ronnie Belliard2B · MIL
Ron Hunt2B · WSH
JSJunior Spivey
2B · ARI
Don Blasingame2B · STL
Dave Cash2B · PIT
Joey Wendle2B · TB
_(cropped).jpg/330px-Seattle_Mariners_(9440344714)_(cropped).jpg)
Robby Thompson2B · SF
Jorge Orta2B · CHW
Top all-time MLB second basemen — November 2026
See the full top list →No top list yet this month — your picks and finished rankings start it.
How a face-off works
A face-off sets two sides against each other across a line. Each row is a matchup, and you call it for the left, the right, or even.
Play matchups goes through the rows one at a time, as big as your screen allows.
The greatest second basemen in MLB history, by their honors.
Every pick and every finished ranking here counts toward the top all-time MLB second basemen for November 2026.
How to make yours
- Pick how many rows and what mix of matchups to deal.
- Call each row: left, right or even.
- Share the score, or save it for others to try.
- To add someone who isn't there, search for them in the box under the board or use + Add.
- Your board stays in this browser while you work. Save it to your profile, download the picture, or share a link.