All-time Cleveland Guardians bracket

289 players who played for the Guardians, greatest for the team first; search for anyone else. Fill out a all-time Cleveland Guardians bracket.

PlaySize

Pick a champion to submit your bracket.

Save to my profile keeps it to come back to and keep ranking. Submit your ranking adds it to this month's top list.

Tap the winner of each match · 15 matches left

Round of 16

Quarterfinals

Semifinals

Final

Seeds

Drag to reorder (or tap one, then tap where it goes). The top 16 are in. Changing seeds keeps the picks that still fit.

1

Andre Dawson1973–1996

2

Jim Thome1991–2012

3

CC Sabathia2001–2019

4

Lou Boudreau1938–1952

5

Early Wynn1939–1963

6

Frank Robinson1956–1976

7

Bob Feller1936–1956

8

Larry Doby1947–1959

9

Earl Averill1929–1941

10

Tris Speaker1907–1928

11

Bob Lemon1941–1958

12

Gaylord Perry1962–1983

13

Stan Coveleski1912–1928

14

Cy Young1890–1911

15

Corey Kluber2011–2023

16

Nap Lajoie1896–1916

–

Elmer Flick1898–1910

–

Bartolo Colón1997–2018

–

Bert Blyleven1970–1992

–

Dennis Eckersley1975–1998

–

Joe Sewell1920–1933

–

Trevor Bauer2012–2023

–

Cliff Lee2002–2014

–

Manny Ramirez1993–2011

–

Shane Bieber2018–2026

–

Minnie Miñoso1949–1980

–

Eddie Murray1977–1997

–

Joe Gordon

–

Roberto Alomar1988–2004

–

Francisco Lindor2015–2026

–

Kenny Lofton1991–2007

–

Grady Sizemore2004–2015

–

Omar Vizquel1989–2012

–

Buddy Bell1972–1989

–

Hoyt Wilhelm

–

Orel Hershiser

–

Lance Parrish1977–1988

–

Al Lopez

–

Yan Gomes2012–2024

–

Carlos Santana2010–2026

–

José Ramírez2013–2026

–

Choo Shin-soo2005–2020

–

Hal Newhouser1939–1955

–

Julio Franco1982–2007

–

Víctor Martínez2002–2018

–

Asdrúbal Cabrera2007–2021

–

Jhonny Peralta2003–2017

–

Phil Niekro1964–1987

–

Sam Rice

–

Ray Fosse1967–1975

–

Del Crandall1949–1963

–

Michael Brantley2009–2023

–

Satchel Paige1948–1965

–

Dick Williams

–

Luis Tiant1964–1982

–

Rocky Colavito1955–1968

–

Doug Jones1982–2000

–

Sherm Lollar1946–1963

–

Travis Fryman1990–2002

–

Jason Kipnis2011–2021

–

Juan González

–

Andre Thornton1973–1987

–

Tommy Harper1962–1974

–

Wes Ferrell1927–1941

–

Roberto Hernández2006–2016

–

Al Rosen

–

Brandon Phillips2002–2018

–

Walter Johnson1907–1927

–

José Mesa1987–2007

–

Justin Masterson2008–2015

–

Danny Salazar2013–2019

–

Boog Powell

–

Roger Maris1957–1968

–

Rick Sutcliffe

–

Rick Manning1975–1987

–

Jim Perry

–

Dean Chance

–

Jeff Kent1992–2008

–

Ellis Burks1987–2004

–

David Justice1989–2002

Top all-time Cleveland Guardians — November 2026

See the full top list →

No top list yet this month — your picks and finished rankings start it.

About this bracket

A knockout bracket: pick the winner of every matchup, round by round, until one is left.

289 players who played for the Guardians, greatest for the team first; search for anyone else.

Every pick and every finished ranking here counts toward the top all-time Cleveland Guardians for November 2026.

How to use it

Choose a size, from 4 to 64.
Click the winner of each matchup to move them on.
Change a pick at any time; later rounds update.
Download image saves a picture with your name or logo on it; Copy link shares this exact board. Your progress is kept in this browser.