All-time Cleveland Guardians Mount Rushmore
289 players who played for the Guardians, greatest for the team first; search for anyone else. Carve your all-time Cleveland Guardians Mount Rushmore.
Fill all 4 to submit (4 left).
Save to my profile keeps it to come back to and keep ranking. Submit your ranking adds it to this month's top list.
1
2
3
4
80 to choose from · drag one onto a spot, or tap it then the spot
.jpg/330px-Andre_Dawson_in_the_Cubs_dugout_(cropped).jpg)
Andre DawsonCF · CLE
Jim ThomeDH/1B · CLE
CC SabathiaP · CLE
Lou BoudreauSS · CLE
Early WynnSP · CLE
Frank RobinsonLF · CLE
Bob FellerSP · CLE
Larry DobyCF · CLE
Earl AverillCF · CLE
)_LOC_2163465876.jpg/330px-(Tris_Speaker%2C_Boston%2C_AL_(baseball))_LOC_2163465876.jpg)
Tris SpeakerCF · CLE
Bob LemonP · CLE
Gaylord PerrySP · CLE
Stan CoveleskiP · CLE
Cy YoungP · CLE
Corey KluberSP · CLE
Nap Lajoie2B · CLE
Elmer FlickRF · CLE
Bartolo ColónP · CLE
Bert BlylevenP · CLE
Dennis EckersleyP · CLE
Joe SewellCLE
Trevor BauerSP · CLE
Cliff LeeP · CLE
Manny RamirezDH/LF · CLE
Shane BieberP · CLE
Minnie MiñosoLF · CLE
Eddie MurrayDH/1B · CLE
.jpg/330px-Joe_Gordon_1942_(2).jpg)
Joe Gordon2B · CLE
.jpg/330px-Roberto_Alomar_(cropped).jpg)
Roberto AlomarCLE
Francisco LindorSS · CLE
_(cropped).jpg/330px-Kenny_Lofton_(48250695222)_(cropped).jpg)
Kenny LoftonCF · CLE
Grady SizemoreCF · CLE
Omar VizquelSS · CLE
Buddy Bell3B · CLE
Hoyt WilhelmRP · CLE
Orel HershiserP · CLE
Lance ParrishC · CLE
Al LopezC · CLE
Yan GomesC · CLE
Carlos SantanaC/1B · CLE
José RamírezSS · CLE
Choo Shin-sooRF · CLE
Hal NewhouserP · CLE
Julio FrancoCLE
Víctor MartínezDH · CLE
Asdrúbal CabreraSS · CLE
Jhonny PeraltaSS · CLE
Phil NiekroSP/P · CLE
Sam RiceRF · CLE
Ray FosseC · CLE
Del CrandallC · CLE
Michael BrantleyOF · CLE
.jpg/330px-12447v_Satchel_Paige_seated_in_front_of_a_portrait_of_himself_in_a_baseball_uniform_(cropped).jpg)
Satchel PaigeP · CLE
Dick WilliamsLF · CLE
Luis TiantP · CLE
Rocky ColavitoRF · CLE
Doug JonesP · CLE
Sherm LollarC · CLE
.jpg/330px-Travis_Fryman_-_18776470213_(cropped).jpg)
Travis Fryman3B · CLE
Jason Kipnis2B/CF · CLE
.png/330px-Juan_Gonzalez_(iEUW3DbyxP4).png)
Juan GonzálezDH · CLE
Andre Thornton1B · CLE
Tommy HarperLF · CLE
Wes FerrellSP · CLE
Roberto HernándezP · CLE
Al Rosen3B · CLE
Brandon Phillips2B · CLE
Walter JohnsonP · CLE
.jpg/330px-Jos%C3%A9_Mesa_(cropped).jpg)
José MesaRP · CLE
Justin MastersonSP · CLE
Danny SalazarSP · CLE
Boog Powell1B · CLE
Roger MarisRF · CLE
.jpg/330px-Rick_Sutcliffe_2014_(cropped).jpg)
Rick SutcliffeSP · CLE
Rick ManningCF · CLE
Jim PerryP · CLE
Dean ChanceP · CLE
Jeff Kent2B · CLE
Ellis BurksCF · CLE
David JusticeOF · CLE
Top all-time Cleveland Guardians — November 2026
See the full top list →No top list yet this month — your picks and finished rankings start it.
About this Mount Rushmore
Four spots, for the four who define it. Who makes the mountain?
289 players who played for the Guardians, greatest for the team first; search for anyone else.
Every pick and every finished ranking here counts toward the top all-time Cleveland Guardians for November 2026.
How to use it
- Click a spot to choose who goes there.
- Drag one face onto another to swap them.
- Download image saves a picture with your name or logo on it; Copy link shares this exact board. Your progress is kept in this browser.