Top 9 all-time Cleveland Guardians
289 players who played for the Guardians, greatest for the team first; search for anyone else. Pick your top 9 all-time Cleveland Guardians, numbered 1 to 9.
Fill all 9 squares to submit your top 9 (9 left).
Save to my profile keeps it to come back to and keep ranking. Submit your ranking adds it to this month's top list.
80 to choose from · drag into a square, or tap a tile then a square
.jpg/330px-Andre_Dawson_in_the_Cubs_dugout_(cropped).jpg)
Andre DawsonCF · CLE
Jim ThomeDH/1B · CLE
CC SabathiaP · CLE
Lou BoudreauSS · CLE
Early WynnSP · CLE
Frank RobinsonLF · CLE
Bob FellerSP · CLE
Larry DobyCF · CLE
Earl AverillCF · CLE
)_LOC_2163465876.jpg/330px-(Tris_Speaker%2C_Boston%2C_AL_(baseball))_LOC_2163465876.jpg)
Tris SpeakerCF · CLE
Bob LemonP · CLE
Gaylord PerrySP · CLE
Stan CoveleskiP · CLE
Cy YoungP · CLE
Corey KluberSP · CLE
Nap Lajoie2B · CLE
Elmer FlickRF · CLE
Bartolo ColónP · CLE
Bert BlylevenP · CLE
Dennis EckersleyP · CLE
Joe SewellCLE
Trevor BauerSP · CLE
Cliff LeeP · CLE
Manny RamirezDH/LF · CLE
Shane BieberP · CLE
Minnie MiñosoLF · CLE
Eddie MurrayDH/1B · CLE
.jpg/330px-Joe_Gordon_1942_(2).jpg)
Joe Gordon2B · CLE
.jpg/330px-Roberto_Alomar_(cropped).jpg)
Roberto AlomarCLE
Francisco LindorSS · CLE
_(cropped).jpg/330px-Kenny_Lofton_(48250695222)_(cropped).jpg)
Kenny LoftonCF · CLE
Grady SizemoreCF · CLE
Omar VizquelSS · CLE
Buddy Bell3B · CLE
Hoyt WilhelmRP · CLE
Orel HershiserP · CLE
Lance ParrishC · CLE
Al LopezC · CLE
Yan GomesC · CLE
Carlos SantanaC/1B · CLE
José RamírezSS · CLE
Choo Shin-sooRF · CLE
Hal NewhouserP · CLE
Julio FrancoCLE
Víctor MartínezDH · CLE
Asdrúbal CabreraSS · CLE
Jhonny PeraltaSS · CLE
Phil NiekroSP/P · CLE
Sam RiceRF · CLE
Ray FosseC · CLE
Del CrandallC · CLE
Michael BrantleyOF · CLE
.jpg/330px-12447v_Satchel_Paige_seated_in_front_of_a_portrait_of_himself_in_a_baseball_uniform_(cropped).jpg)
Satchel PaigeP · CLE
Dick WilliamsLF · CLE
Luis TiantP · CLE
Rocky ColavitoRF · CLE
Doug JonesP · CLE
Sherm LollarC · CLE
.jpg/330px-Travis_Fryman_-_18776470213_(cropped).jpg)
Travis Fryman3B · CLE
Jason Kipnis2B/CF · CLE
.png/330px-Juan_Gonzalez_(iEUW3DbyxP4).png)
Juan GonzálezDH · CLE
Andre Thornton1B · CLE
Tommy HarperLF · CLE
Wes FerrellSP · CLE
Roberto HernándezP · CLE
Al Rosen3B · CLE
Brandon Phillips2B · CLE
Walter JohnsonP · CLE
.jpg/330px-Jos%C3%A9_Mesa_(cropped).jpg)
José MesaRP · CLE
Justin MastersonSP · CLE
Danny SalazarSP · CLE
Boog Powell1B · CLE
Roger MarisRF · CLE
.jpg/330px-Rick_Sutcliffe_2014_(cropped).jpg)
Rick SutcliffeSP · CLE
Rick ManningCF · CLE
Jim PerryP · CLE
Dean ChanceP · CLE
Jeff Kent2B · CLE
Ellis BurksCF · CLE
David JusticeOF · CLE
Top all-time Cleveland Guardians — November 2026
See the full top list →No top list yet this month — your picks and finished rankings start it.
About this top 9
A numbered 3×3 of your favourites, best first. Go bigger with a top 16 or top 25.
289 players who played for the Guardians, greatest for the team first; search for anyone else.
Every pick and every finished ranking here counts toward the top all-time Cleveland Guardians for November 2026.
How to use it
- Drag your number one into square 1, then fill the rest in order.
- Drag one square onto another to swap them.
- Switch to 16 or 25 for a longer list.
- Missing someone? Use + Add or the search box under the board to bring in any player, team or legend.
- Download image saves a picture with your name or logo on it; Copy link shares this exact board. Your progress is kept in this browser.