All-time New York City FC tier list
75 players who played for the NYCFC, greatest for the team first; search for anyone else. Rank all-time New York City FC from S to F.
Place at least 10 to submit your ranking (0 so far).
Save to my profile keeps it to come back to and keep ranking. Submit your ranking adds it to this month's top list.
S
A
B
C
D
E
F
Drag a tile into a tier, or tap it then tap a tier
.jpg/330px-David_Villa_NYCFC_vs._Houston_Dynamo-_5-30-2015_(18102079848).jpg)
David VillaFW · NYC
.jpg/330px-20150616_-_Portugal_-_Italie_-_Gen%C3%A8ve_-_Andrea_Pirlo_(cropped).jpg)
Andrea PirloMF · NYC
Ronald MatarritaNYC
Alexander RingMF · NYC
James SandsMF/DF · NYC
_-_Sweden_vs_Romania_23_March_2019.jpg/330px-Alexandru_Mitrita_(cropped)_-_Sweden_vs_Romania_23_March_2019.jpg)
Alexandru MitrițăNYC
Frank LampardMF · NYC
.jpg/330px-Matt_Freese_NYCFC_v_Cincinnati_22_Apr_26-40_(cropped).jpg)
Matt FreeseGK · NYC
.jpg/330px-CINvSKC_2019-04-07_-_Rodney_Wallace_(33683771348).jpg)
Rodney WallaceDF · NYC
_(cropped).jpg/330px-Brad_Stuver_2017-06-14_(35692567831)_(cropped).jpg)
Brad StuverGK · NYC
.jpg/330px-Yangel_Herrera_(cropped).jpg)
Yangel HerreraMF · NYC
Andoni IraolaNYC
Josh SaundersGK · NYC
.jpg/330px-Austria_vs._USA_2013-11-19_(097).jpg)
Mix DiskerudMF · NYC
Gedion ZelalemMF · NYC
.jpg/330px-Taty_Castellanos_NYCvATL-06.12.25-041_(cropped).jpg)
Taty CastellanosFW · NYC
_(cropped).jpg/330px-Josh_Williams_2017-06-14_(35691889651)_(cropped).jpg)
Josh WilliamsDF · NYC
.jpg/330px-Jack_Harrison_13092025_(4).jpg)
Jack HarrisonMF · NYC
Maxime ChanotDF · NYC
_(Acevedo_crop).jpg/330px-CINvNYC_2022-06-29_-_Nicol%C3%A1s_Acevedo%2C_H%C3%A9ber%2C_Maxime_Chanot%2C_Tayvon_Gray%2C_Talles_Magno_(52187857895)_(Acevedo_crop).jpg)
Nicolás AcevedoMF · NYC
.jpg/330px-SC_Wiener_Neustadt_vs._SCR_Altach_20141206_(044).jpg)
Ismael Tajouri-ShradiMF · NYC
Adam NemecFW · NYC
JLJonathan Lewis
FW · NYC
TTTony Taylor
FW · NYC
.jpg/330px-JEFFERSON_MENA_(32065994932).jpg)
Jefferson MenaDF · NYC
JTJuan Pablo Torres
MF · NYC
.jpg/330px-Tayvon_Gray_CF_Montreal_NYCFC_6.28.25-043_(cropped).jpg)
Tayvon GrayDF · NYC
Jason HernandezDF · NYC
SASaad Abdul-Salaam
DF · NYC
DMDiego Martínez
DF · NYC
AngeliñoNYC
_(cropped).jpg/330px-CINvOCB_2017-05-13_-_Tony_Rocha_(34494682032)_(cropped).jpg)
Tony RochaMF · NYC
MCMiguel Camargo
MF · NYC
.jpg/330px-Joe_Scally_Australia_v_USA_19_June_2026-68_(cropped).jpg)
Joe ScallyDF · NYC
Pablo Álvarez NúñezMF · NYC
AMAbdi Mohamed
DF · NYC
Jesús MedinaMF · NYC
ARAndre Rawls
GK · NYC
TMThomas McNamara
MF · NYC
CBConnor Brandt
MF · NYC
.jpg/330px-Chris_Wingert_NYCFC_vs._Houston_Dynamo-_5-30-2015_(17667269214).jpg)
Chris WingertNYC
Andrew JacobsonMF · NYC
.jpg/330px-Khiry_SHelton_NYCFC_vs._Houston_Dynamo-_5-30-2015_(cropped).jpg)
Khiry SheltonFW · NYC
RAR. J. Allen
DF · NYC
.jpg/330px-Justin_Haak_CF_Montreal_NYCFC_6.28.25-081_(cropped).jpg)
Justin HaakMF · NYC
Andraž StrunaDF · NYC
.jpg/330px-Maximo_Carrizo_CF_Montreal_NYCFC_6.28.25-036_(cropped).jpg)
Maximo CarrizoMF · NYC
.jpg/330px-Luis_Barraza_NYCFC_vs_DC_United_on_Aug_30_2025-028_(cropped).jpg)
Luis BarrazaGK · NYC
.jpg/330px-Mehdi_Ballouchy_CF_Montreal_NYCFC_6.28.25-042_(cropped).jpg)
Mehdi BallouchyMF · NYC
.jpg/330px-Ben_Sweat_2017_(cropped).jpg)
Ben SweatDF · NYC
Jeb BrovskyDF · NYC
Patrick MullinsFW · NYC
.jpg/330px-Fr%C3%A9d%C3%A9ric_Brillant_DC_United_2020-08-21_1_(cropped).jpg)
Frédéric BrillantDF · NYC
MLMikey Lopez
MF/DF · NYC
KWKwame Watson-Siriboe
DF · NYC
EWEthan White
DF · NYC
KPKwadwo Poku
MF · NYC
SGShannon Gomez
DF · NYC
.jpg/330px-Kwame_Awuah_in_2019_with_Forge_FC_(cropped).jpg)
Kwame AwuahMF · NYC
.jpg/330px-Steven_Mendoza-7379_(cropped).jpg)
Stiven MendozaNYC
Kai TrewinMF · NYC
_(cropped).jpg/330px-HFDvPGH_2021-05-15_-_Jeff_Caldwell_(51182693794)_(cropped).jpg)
Jeff CaldwellGK · NYC
Eric MillerDF · NYC
SFShay Facey
DF · NYC
FBFederico Bravo
NYC
Sebastián VelásquezMF · NYC
NGNed Grabavoy
MF · NYC
_(cropped).jpg/330px-Sean_Okoli_(29125672544)_(cropped).jpg)
Sean OkoliFW · NYC
Ryan MearaGK · NYC
Eirik Holmen JohansenGK · NYC
_053_(cropped).jpg/330px-NCFC_vs_Charlotte_(2025_US_Open_Cup)_053_(cropped).jpg)
Akira FitzgeraldGK · NYC
JCJavier Calle
MF · NYC
MDMatt Dunn
MF · NYC
AMAndrés Mendoza
DF · NYC
Jo Inge BergetNYC
Top all-time New York City FC — November 2026
See the full top list →No top list yet this month — your picks and finished rankings start it.
About this tier list
A tier list sorts everyone into rows from S (the best) to F. Rename the rows, recolour them, or add your own.
75 players who played for the NYCFC, greatest for the team first; search for anyone else.
Every pick and every finished ranking here counts toward the top all-time New York City FC for November 2026.
How to use it
- Drag each tile into a tier, or tap a tile and then a row.
- Reorder tiles within a row to rank inside the tier.
- Use the sort menu and the Players bar to change who you start with.
- Missing someone? Use + Add or the search box under the board to bring in any player, team or legend.
- Download image saves a picture with your name or logo on it; Copy link shares this exact board. Your progress is kept in this browser.