All-time New York City FC Mount Rushmore
75 players who played for the NYCFC, greatest for the team first; search for anyone else. Make an all-time New York City FC Mount Rushmore with room for exactly four faces.
Fill all 4 to submit (4 left).
Save to my profile keeps it to come back to and keep ranking. Submit your ranking adds it to this month's top list.
1
2
3
4
75 to choose from · drag one onto a spot, or tap it then the spot
.jpg/330px-David_Villa_NYCFC_vs._Houston_Dynamo-_5-30-2015_(18102079848).jpg)
David VillaFW · NYC
.jpg/330px-20150616_-_Portugal_-_Italie_-_Gen%C3%A8ve_-_Andrea_Pirlo_(cropped).jpg)
Andrea PirloMF · NYC
Ronald MatarritaNYC
Alexander RingMF · NYC
James SandsMF/DF · NYC
_-_Sweden_vs_Romania_23_March_2019.jpg/330px-Alexandru_Mitrita_(cropped)_-_Sweden_vs_Romania_23_March_2019.jpg)
Alexandru MitrițăNYC
Frank LampardMF · NYC
.jpg/330px-Matt_Freese_NYCFC_v_Cincinnati_22_Apr_26-40_(cropped).jpg)
Matt FreeseGK · NYC
.jpg/330px-CINvSKC_2019-04-07_-_Rodney_Wallace_(33683771348).jpg)
Rodney WallaceDF · NYC
_(cropped).jpg/330px-Brad_Stuver_2017-06-14_(35692567831)_(cropped).jpg)
Brad StuverGK · NYC
.jpg/330px-Yangel_Herrera_(cropped).jpg)
Yangel HerreraMF · NYC
Andoni IraolaNYC
Josh SaundersGK · NYC
.jpg/330px-Austria_vs._USA_2013-11-19_(097).jpg)
Mix DiskerudMF · NYC
Gedion ZelalemMF · NYC
.jpg/330px-Taty_Castellanos_NYCvATL-06.12.25-041_(cropped).jpg)
Taty CastellanosFW · NYC
_(cropped).jpg/330px-Josh_Williams_2017-06-14_(35691889651)_(cropped).jpg)
Josh WilliamsDF · NYC
.jpg/330px-Jack_Harrison_13092025_(4).jpg)
Jack HarrisonMF · NYC
Maxime ChanotDF · NYC
_(Acevedo_crop).jpg/330px-CINvNYC_2022-06-29_-_Nicol%C3%A1s_Acevedo%2C_H%C3%A9ber%2C_Maxime_Chanot%2C_Tayvon_Gray%2C_Talles_Magno_(52187857895)_(Acevedo_crop).jpg)
Nicolás AcevedoMF · NYC
.jpg/330px-SC_Wiener_Neustadt_vs._SCR_Altach_20141206_(044).jpg)
Ismael Tajouri-ShradiMF · NYC
Adam NemecFW · NYC
JLJonathan Lewis
FW · NYC
TTTony Taylor
FW · NYC
.jpg/330px-JEFFERSON_MENA_(32065994932).jpg)
Jefferson MenaDF · NYC
JTJuan Pablo Torres
MF · NYC
.jpg/330px-Tayvon_Gray_CF_Montreal_NYCFC_6.28.25-043_(cropped).jpg)
Tayvon GrayDF · NYC
Jason HernandezDF · NYC
SASaad Abdul-Salaam
DF · NYC
DMDiego Martínez
DF · NYC
AngeliñoNYC
_(cropped).jpg/330px-CINvOCB_2017-05-13_-_Tony_Rocha_(34494682032)_(cropped).jpg)
Tony RochaMF · NYC
MCMiguel Camargo
MF · NYC
.jpg/330px-Joe_Scally_Australia_v_USA_19_June_2026-68_(cropped).jpg)
Joe ScallyDF · NYC
Pablo Álvarez NúñezMF · NYC
AMAbdi Mohamed
DF · NYC
Jesús MedinaMF · NYC
ARAndre Rawls
GK · NYC
TMThomas McNamara
MF · NYC
CBConnor Brandt
MF · NYC
.jpg/330px-Chris_Wingert_NYCFC_vs._Houston_Dynamo-_5-30-2015_(17667269214).jpg)
Chris WingertNYC
Andrew JacobsonMF · NYC
.jpg/330px-Khiry_SHelton_NYCFC_vs._Houston_Dynamo-_5-30-2015_(cropped).jpg)
Khiry SheltonFW · NYC
RAR. J. Allen
DF · NYC
.jpg/330px-Justin_Haak_CF_Montreal_NYCFC_6.28.25-081_(cropped).jpg)
Justin HaakMF · NYC
Andraž StrunaDF · NYC
.jpg/330px-Maximo_Carrizo_CF_Montreal_NYCFC_6.28.25-036_(cropped).jpg)
Maximo CarrizoMF · NYC
.jpg/330px-Luis_Barraza_NYCFC_vs_DC_United_on_Aug_30_2025-028_(cropped).jpg)
Luis BarrazaGK · NYC
.jpg/330px-Mehdi_Ballouchy_CF_Montreal_NYCFC_6.28.25-042_(cropped).jpg)
Mehdi BallouchyMF · NYC
.jpg/330px-Ben_Sweat_2017_(cropped).jpg)
Ben SweatDF · NYC
Jeb BrovskyDF · NYC
Patrick MullinsFW · NYC
.jpg/330px-Fr%C3%A9d%C3%A9ric_Brillant_DC_United_2020-08-21_1_(cropped).jpg)
Frédéric BrillantDF · NYC
MLMikey Lopez
MF/DF · NYC
KWKwame Watson-Siriboe
DF · NYC
EWEthan White
DF · NYC
KPKwadwo Poku
MF · NYC
SGShannon Gomez
DF · NYC
.jpg/330px-Kwame_Awuah_in_2019_with_Forge_FC_(cropped).jpg)
Kwame AwuahMF · NYC
.jpg/330px-Steven_Mendoza-7379_(cropped).jpg)
Stiven MendozaNYC
Kai TrewinMF · NYC
_(cropped).jpg/330px-HFDvPGH_2021-05-15_-_Jeff_Caldwell_(51182693794)_(cropped).jpg)
Jeff CaldwellGK · NYC
Eric MillerDF · NYC
SFShay Facey
DF · NYC
FBFederico Bravo
NYC
Sebastián VelásquezMF · NYC
NGNed Grabavoy
MF · NYC
_(cropped).jpg/330px-Sean_Okoli_(29125672544)_(cropped).jpg)
Sean OkoliFW · NYC
Ryan MearaGK · NYC
Eirik Holmen JohansenGK · NYC
_053_(cropped).jpg/330px-NCFC_vs_Charlotte_(2025_US_Open_Cup)_053_(cropped).jpg)
Akira FitzgeraldGK · NYC
JCJavier Calle
MF · NYC
MDMatt Dunn
MF · NYC
AMAndrés Mendoza
DF · NYC
Jo Inge BergetNYC
Top all-time New York City FC — November 2026
See the full top list →No top list yet this month — your picks and finished rankings start it.
What a Mount Rushmore is for
The four faces are carved into the mountain in order, first to fourth, each with a name plate below.
Make one for a single era or team, and another for all time, to see how your four players change.
75 players who played for the NYCFC, greatest for the team first; search for anyone else.
Every pick and every finished ranking here counts toward the top all-time New York City FC for November 2026.
Step by step
- Fill the four spots from first to fourth.
- Use the ✕ on a face to clear it and choose again.
- The search box under the board finds anyone else you want to add.
- Download image saves a picture of your board with your name or logo on it, and Copy link shares this exact board.