All-time New York City FC, head to head
75 players who played for the NYCFC, greatest for the team first; search for anyone else. Choose between two players at a time, and the page builds your all-time New York City FC ranking from your picks.
Which is better? Tap one, or drag it onto “vs” · 0 answered, about 128 to go
.jpg/330px-20150616_-_Portugal_-_Italie_-_Gen%C3%A8ve_-_Andrea_Pirlo_(cropped).jpg)
Andrea PirloMF · NYC
vsDrop the winner
.jpg/330px-David_Villa_NYCFC_vs._Houston_Dynamo-_5-30-2015_(18102079848).jpg)
David VillaFW · NYC
- 1
David Villa
FW · NYC
Top all-time New York City FC — November 2026
See the full top list →No top list yet this month — your picks and finished rankings start it.
About this head to head
Each answer places one more entry in your ranking, which grows below the matchup as you go.
The counter shows about how many picks are left, so you can stop and come back later.
75 players who played for the NYCFC, greatest for the team first; search for anyone else.
Every pick and every finished ranking here counts toward the top all-time New York City FC for November 2026.
How to use it
- Pick the better player of each pair, by tapping it or dragging it onto vs.
- Keep going; the count shows how many picks are left.
- Your ranking builds below as you go.
- Use the bar above the board to switch to another group, such as stars, one position or Hall of Famers.
- If someone is missing, use + Add or the search box under the board to bring them in.
- When you're done, download the picture or copy a link that opens your board as you left it.